"Stay the course"
About this Quote
"Stay the course" is a deceptively spare command, the kind that smuggles an entire moral universe into four blunt syllables. Coming from J. Gresham Machen, a theologian best known for fighting modernist currents in early 20th-century American Protestantism, the phrase isn’t self-help pablum. It’s trench language: hold the line, don’t defect, don’t get seduced by novelty masquerading as progress.
Machen’s world was one where institutions were being renegotiated in real time: higher criticism, evolutionary science, and the social gospel were pressuring churches to rebrand Christianity as ethics plus optimism. His intent, then, is less about personal grit than doctrinal fidelity. "Course" implies something mapped in advance - a fixed destination and a correct route - which is precisely the point. The subtext is polemical: if there is a course, there are also wrong turns, drift, and betrayal. It frames disagreement not as a healthy pluralism but as deviation.
Rhetorically, the phrase works because it sounds modest while demanding total allegiance. It avoids theological vocabulary, which makes it portable, quotable, and hard to argue with in the moment; who wants to be the one advocating quitting? Yet that plainness is strategic. It converts a complex intellectual controversy into a test of character: steadfast people endure; the wavering compromise.
Read in context, it’s a slogan for minority resistance. Not a promise that the path is easy, but a warning that the pressure to accommodate will feel reasonable, even virtuous. Machen’s genius was to make stubbornness sound like duty.
Machen’s world was one where institutions were being renegotiated in real time: higher criticism, evolutionary science, and the social gospel were pressuring churches to rebrand Christianity as ethics plus optimism. His intent, then, is less about personal grit than doctrinal fidelity. "Course" implies something mapped in advance - a fixed destination and a correct route - which is precisely the point. The subtext is polemical: if there is a course, there are also wrong turns, drift, and betrayal. It frames disagreement not as a healthy pluralism but as deviation.
Rhetorically, the phrase works because it sounds modest while demanding total allegiance. It avoids theological vocabulary, which makes it portable, quotable, and hard to argue with in the moment; who wants to be the one advocating quitting? Yet that plainness is strategic. It converts a complex intellectual controversy into a test of character: steadfast people endure; the wavering compromise.
Read in context, it’s a slogan for minority resistance. Not a promise that the path is easy, but a warning that the pressure to accommodate will feel reasonable, even virtuous. Machen’s genius was to make stubbornness sound like duty.
Quote Details
| Topic | Perseverance |
|---|
More Quotes by John
Add to List




