"Studios are passe for me. I'd rather play in a garage, in a truck, or a rehearsal hall, a club, or a basement"
About this Quote
Neil Young isn’t just romanticizing grit here; he’s drawing a bright line between music as product and music as event. “Studios are passe for me” lands like a shrug at the entire apparatus of polish: budgets, perfectionism, the antiseptic silence that turns a song into a deliverable. The list that follows - garage, truck, rehearsal hall, club, basement - isn’t random color. It’s a map of places where sound leaks, neighbors complain, amps hum, and takes aren’t curated so much as survived. Young is telling you he trusts the mess because the mess contains the human.
The intent is practical and ideological. Practically, those spaces are where musicians test songs against air and bodies, not against a waveform. Ideologically, it’s a rejection of the mid-to-late 20th-century studio-as-laboratory mentality that prized control and infinite revision. Young’s career has been a running argument that immediacy can beat fidelity: live-ish recordings, audible room tone, the feeling that the band could fall apart at any second and chooses not to.
The subtext is also a status flex disguised as anti-status: only an artist with his legacy can dismiss the studio while knowing the industry will still listen. But it’s a defensible flex. In an era when “content” gets sanded down for playlists and algorithms, Young stakes out a stubbornly physical definition of authenticity: music that’s made somewhere specific, under imperfect conditions, with real constraints. The constraints are the point.
The intent is practical and ideological. Practically, those spaces are where musicians test songs against air and bodies, not against a waveform. Ideologically, it’s a rejection of the mid-to-late 20th-century studio-as-laboratory mentality that prized control and infinite revision. Young’s career has been a running argument that immediacy can beat fidelity: live-ish recordings, audible room tone, the feeling that the band could fall apart at any second and chooses not to.
The subtext is also a status flex disguised as anti-status: only an artist with his legacy can dismiss the studio while knowing the industry will still listen. But it’s a defensible flex. In an era when “content” gets sanded down for playlists and algorithms, Young stakes out a stubbornly physical definition of authenticity: music that’s made somewhere specific, under imperfect conditions, with real constraints. The constraints are the point.
Quote Details
| Topic | Music |
|---|
More Quotes by Neil
Add to List
