"Stupidity is also a gift of God, but one mustn't misuse it"
About this Quote
Only a pope could call stupidity a "gift of God" without sounding like he’s simply insulting the room. The line works because it’s both pastoral and cutting: it acknowledges human limitation as part of creation, then snaps the leash tight on how far that limitation can be indulged. John Paul II’s theological move is subtle. If even our weaknesses sit under Providence, then no one gets to claim moral superiority on the basis of being smarter; humility is mandatory. But the second clause refuses the modern alibi that ignorance is harmless. A gift can be squandered. Stupidity becomes dangerous when it’s weaponized into stubbornness, cynicism, or convenient denial.
The subtext is aimed at two temptations John Paul II battled across his pontificate: the arrogance of elites who treat faith as backwards, and the complacency of believers who treat faith as a substitute for thought. Coming out of a 20th century defined by ideological machines - Nazism, communism, consumerism - he had seen what happens when people outsource conscience to slogans. "Don’t misuse it" reads like a warning against moral laziness: not knowing is one thing; choosing not to know, or refusing to learn when consequences are clear, is another.
Rhetorically, the sentence uses a bait-and-switch. It begins with radical generosity (even folly is under God’s umbrella) and ends with responsibility. It’s mercy with teeth: you are allowed to be limited, but you’re not allowed to make limitation your identity or your excuse.
The subtext is aimed at two temptations John Paul II battled across his pontificate: the arrogance of elites who treat faith as backwards, and the complacency of believers who treat faith as a substitute for thought. Coming out of a 20th century defined by ideological machines - Nazism, communism, consumerism - he had seen what happens when people outsource conscience to slogans. "Don’t misuse it" reads like a warning against moral laziness: not knowing is one thing; choosing not to know, or refusing to learn when consequences are clear, is another.
Rhetorically, the sentence uses a bait-and-switch. It begins with radical generosity (even folly is under God’s umbrella) and ends with responsibility. It’s mercy with teeth: you are allowed to be limited, but you’re not allowed to make limitation your identity or your excuse.
Quote Details
| Topic | Witty One-Liners |
|---|---|
| Source | Later attribution: The Psychology of Stupidity (Jean-Francois Marmion, 2020) modern compilationISBN: 9781529053845 · ID: VlLlDwAAQBAJ
Evidence: ... Pope John Paul II In her work on the power of vulnerability,1 Brené Brown of the University of Houston tackles the difference between embarrassment, guilt, and shame ... Stupidity is also a gift of God, but one mustn't misuse it. Other candidates (1) Pope John Paul II (Pope John Paul II) compilation35.9% it consists in sharing the very life of god the loftiness of this supernatural |
More Quotes by Pope
Add to List






