"Success and failure are equally disastrous"
About this Quote
Tennessee Williams doesn’t hand you a moral; he hands you a trap. “Success and failure are equally disastrous” lands like a paradox, but it’s really a diagnosis of the Williams universe, where external outcomes don’t rescue you from internal weather. In his plays, the real catastrophe isn’t losing; it’s believing that winning will finally make you safe.
The line takes aim at America’s favorite fairy tale: that success is redemption. Williams, who knew both acclaim and its hangover, suggests the opposite. Success can be just another spotlight that exaggerates what you hoped it would hide: loneliness, addiction, the dread that you’re a fraud who got lucky. Failure, meanwhile, isn’t a purifying lesson; it’s simply the same ache without the applause. Either way, you’re still you, stuck with your appetites and wounds.
The intent feels less cynical than exhausted. Williams writes characters who chase validation the way Blanche DuBois chases kindness: as a substitute for stability. When success arrives, it demands maintenance, performance, repetition. You don’t get to rest; you get to reenact the version of yourself that sold. Failure demands its own performance, too: shame, explanations, the social ritual of “learning from it.” Disaster is the common denominator because both outcomes keep you oriented toward judgment instead of desire.
In the mid-century American pressure cooker of respectability and achievement, Williams offers a brutal clarity: the scoreboard is not the story. The tragedy is mistaking it for one.
The line takes aim at America’s favorite fairy tale: that success is redemption. Williams, who knew both acclaim and its hangover, suggests the opposite. Success can be just another spotlight that exaggerates what you hoped it would hide: loneliness, addiction, the dread that you’re a fraud who got lucky. Failure, meanwhile, isn’t a purifying lesson; it’s simply the same ache without the applause. Either way, you’re still you, stuck with your appetites and wounds.
The intent feels less cynical than exhausted. Williams writes characters who chase validation the way Blanche DuBois chases kindness: as a substitute for stability. When success arrives, it demands maintenance, performance, repetition. You don’t get to rest; you get to reenact the version of yourself that sold. Failure demands its own performance, too: shame, explanations, the social ritual of “learning from it.” Disaster is the common denominator because both outcomes keep you oriented toward judgment instead of desire.
In the mid-century American pressure cooker of respectability and achievement, Williams offers a brutal clarity: the scoreboard is not the story. The tragedy is mistaking it for one.
Quote Details
| Topic | Wisdom |
|---|---|
| Source | Later attribution: The Double Life of Bob Dylan Volume 2: 1966-2021 (Clinton Heylin, 2023) modern compilationISBN: 9781473569935 · ID: EkulEAAAQBAJ
Evidence: ... Success and failure are equally disastrous . Tennessee Williams . Success and failure are both difficult to endure . Along with success come drugs , divorce , fornication ... medication , depression , neurosis and suicide . With failure ... Other candidates (1) Tennessee Williams (Tennessee Williams) compilation33.3% d damn rise and shine rise and shine i say to myself how lucky dead people are t |
More Quotes by Tennessee
Add to List






