"Suffering by nature or chance never seems so painful as suffering inflicted on us by the arbitrary will of another"
About this Quote
Schopenhauer’s real target here isn’t pain itself, but humiliation: the special sting of realizing your misery is optional for someone else. Illness, bad luck, even the indifferent cruelty of nature can feel brutal, yet they at least preserve a kind of metaphysical dignity. No one chose this for you. The moment suffering becomes someone’s decision, it acquires an extra ingredient - contempt. You’re not just hurt; you’ve been positioned beneath another person’s will.
The line is engineered to make “arbitrary” do the moral heavy lifting. Schopenhauer isn’t talking about punishment that claims justification, or conflict between equals. He’s isolating the nightmare scenario of power without reasons: the whim, the caprice, the bureaucrat’s shrug. That’s why this lands less like a general observation and more like an x-ray of domination. It anticipates how modern people experience institutions: not simply as forces, but as moods with consequences.
Context matters. Schopenhauer writes in a Europe reorganized by revolution, empire, and reaction, where authority is visibly man-made and often nakedly self-serving. His broader philosophy frames life as suffering driven by blind “will,” but this sentence narrows the focus from cosmic pessimism to social psychology. The subtext is political even when it pretends not to be: oppression wounds twice, first through harm, then through the message embedded in it - you are at my disposal.
The line is engineered to make “arbitrary” do the moral heavy lifting. Schopenhauer isn’t talking about punishment that claims justification, or conflict between equals. He’s isolating the nightmare scenario of power without reasons: the whim, the caprice, the bureaucrat’s shrug. That’s why this lands less like a general observation and more like an x-ray of domination. It anticipates how modern people experience institutions: not simply as forces, but as moods with consequences.
Context matters. Schopenhauer writes in a Europe reorganized by revolution, empire, and reaction, where authority is visibly man-made and often nakedly self-serving. His broader philosophy frames life as suffering driven by blind “will,” but this sentence narrows the focus from cosmic pessimism to social psychology. The subtext is political even when it pretends not to be: oppression wounds twice, first through harm, then through the message embedded in it - you are at my disposal.
Quote Details
| Topic | Free Will & Fate |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Arthur
Add to List






