"Sure, I've often been misrepresented - anyone frequently quoted has this experience"
About this Quote
Fame, even the low-grade fame of the public intellectual, comes with a tax: your sentences get broken into souvenir fragments and sold back to you as your “views.” Gitlin’s line is a shrug with teeth. The opening “Sure” performs weary consent, a veteran’s acknowledgment that the game is rigged. Then he pivots to an almost breezy general rule - “anyone frequently quoted has this experience” - which quietly dissolves the possibility that his grievance is special pleading. He’s not begging for sympathy; he’s indicting a system.
The intent is defensive without sounding defensive. By framing misrepresentation as the norm, he protects his credibility: if you’ve encountered a distorted Gitlin, the distortion is evidence of media mechanics, not his incoherence. The subtext is about power. Quoting looks like giving someone a voice, but it’s often an act of control: editors and opponents carve a complex argument into a usable weapon, a headline-friendly shard. A sociologist knows that the quote is a social artifact, shaped by institutional incentives - speed, conflict, clarity - that rarely reward nuance.
Context matters here. Gitlin came out of the 60s New Left, then spent decades analyzing how movements are packaged by media. His remark reads like fieldwork from the front lines: once you become “frequently quoted,” you’re no longer just a thinker. You’re raw material. The line lands because it’s both modest and corrosive: it normalizes the injury while exposing the machinery that keeps producing it.
The intent is defensive without sounding defensive. By framing misrepresentation as the norm, he protects his credibility: if you’ve encountered a distorted Gitlin, the distortion is evidence of media mechanics, not his incoherence. The subtext is about power. Quoting looks like giving someone a voice, but it’s often an act of control: editors and opponents carve a complex argument into a usable weapon, a headline-friendly shard. A sociologist knows that the quote is a social artifact, shaped by institutional incentives - speed, conflict, clarity - that rarely reward nuance.
Context matters here. Gitlin came out of the 60s New Left, then spent decades analyzing how movements are packaged by media. His remark reads like fieldwork from the front lines: once you become “frequently quoted,” you’re no longer just a thinker. You’re raw material. The line lands because it’s both modest and corrosive: it normalizes the injury while exposing the machinery that keeps producing it.
Quote Details
| Topic | Writing |
|---|
More Quotes by Todd
Add to List





