"Surely it is much more generous to forgive and remember, than to forgive and forget"
About this Quote
Edgeworth’s line pricks at the tidy moral advice we’ve all heard: forgive and forget. She keeps the first half, then refuses the anesthesia. “Forgive and remember” sounds almost contradictory, but that tension is the point: she’s arguing that real generosity isn’t amnesia, it’s restraint with a clear-eyed memory of what happened.
As a novelist shaped by Enlightenment rationality and the social choreography of late-18th- and early-19th-century Britain and Ireland, Edgeworth understood that injury isn’t only private; it’s reputational, economic, familial. Forgetting can be a luxury, even a form of self-deception, especially for people with less power. To “forget” may simply invite repetition. Remembering, by contrast, is a kind of ethical bookkeeping: you keep the record, you don’t keep the grudge.
The subtext is quietly radical. Edgeworth rejects forgiveness as a sentimental reset button. She implies that forgiveness is not the erasure of consequences but the decision not to weaponize the past. That’s why she calls it “more generous”: it asks more of the forgiver. You must hold two truths at once - that harm was done, and that you will not make your life a courtroom.
The line also carries a social warning. Forgiving and forgetting can flatter the offender, letting them rewrite events and dodge accountability. Forgiving and remembering preserves moral clarity while still offering mercy, a balance Edgeworth’s fiction often stages in drawing rooms where manners mask real stakes.
As a novelist shaped by Enlightenment rationality and the social choreography of late-18th- and early-19th-century Britain and Ireland, Edgeworth understood that injury isn’t only private; it’s reputational, economic, familial. Forgetting can be a luxury, even a form of self-deception, especially for people with less power. To “forget” may simply invite repetition. Remembering, by contrast, is a kind of ethical bookkeeping: you keep the record, you don’t keep the grudge.
The subtext is quietly radical. Edgeworth rejects forgiveness as a sentimental reset button. She implies that forgiveness is not the erasure of consequences but the decision not to weaponize the past. That’s why she calls it “more generous”: it asks more of the forgiver. You must hold two truths at once - that harm was done, and that you will not make your life a courtroom.
The line also carries a social warning. Forgiving and forgetting can flatter the offender, letting them rewrite events and dodge accountability. Forgiving and remembering preserves moral clarity while still offering mercy, a balance Edgeworth’s fiction often stages in drawing rooms where manners mask real stakes.
Quote Details
| Topic | Forgiveness |
|---|
More Quotes by Maria
Add to List
