"Surrealism is a bourgeois disaffection; that its militants thought it universal is only one of the signs that it is typically bourgeois"
About this Quote
The sentence turns on "universal". Sontag is suspicious of movements that universalize their own interior weather. When surrealism’s "militants" (a word that mocks the martial posturing of artistic vanguards) imagine their sensibility applies to everyone, she reads that as a tell: the bourgeois habit of mistaking its own experience for the human condition. This is class critique as epistemology. The scandal isn’t only political; it’s interpretive. Surrealism’s dream logic, erotic shock, and anti-rational theatrics are not neutral tools - they are social artifacts with an address label.
Context matters: Sontag is writing in the postwar moment when avant-garde gestures risk hardening into cultural capital, safely curated by museums and magazines. Her point is less "surrealism is bad" than "watch how rebellion gets domesticated". The bourgeoisie doesn’t just consume dissent; it produces a version of dissent that flatters its self-image as daring, alienated, and deep.
Quote Details
| Topic | Art |
|---|---|
| Source | Evidence: Surrealism is a bourgeois disaffection; that its militants thought it universal is only one of the signs that it is typically bourgeois. (Essay: "Melancholy Objects," p. 41 in the 1977 edition). The quote appears in Susan Sontag's essay "Melancholy Objects," later collected in her book On Photography. In the scanned text, the quote appears on p. 41 of the book, within that essay. The book was first published in the United States and Canada by Farrar, Straus and Giroux in 1977. I found the exact wording in a scan of the essay/book text, and bibliographic sources confirm the 1977 first book publication. I did not verify an earlier magazine appearance from a primary facsimile, so the earliest confirmed primary source I can give with high confidence is the 1977 book publication. Other candidates (1) Stan Brakhage in Rolling Stock, 1980-1990 (Jerry White, 2018) compilation96.6% ... Susan Sontag's assessment , offered in her 1977 book On Photography , that “ the error of the ... Surrealism is a... |
| Cite |
Citation Formats
APA Style (7th ed.)
Sontag, Susan. (2026, March 16). Surrealism is a bourgeois disaffection; that its militants thought it universal is only one of the signs that it is typically bourgeois. FixQuotes. https://fixquotes.com/quotes/surrealism-is-a-bourgeois-disaffection-that-its-117322/
Chicago Style
Sontag, Susan. "Surrealism is a bourgeois disaffection; that its militants thought it universal is only one of the signs that it is typically bourgeois." FixQuotes. March 16, 2026. https://fixquotes.com/quotes/surrealism-is-a-bourgeois-disaffection-that-its-117322/.
MLA Style (9th ed.)
"Surrealism is a bourgeois disaffection; that its militants thought it universal is only one of the signs that it is typically bourgeois." FixQuotes, 16 Mar. 2026, https://fixquotes.com/quotes/surrealism-is-a-bourgeois-disaffection-that-its-117322/. Accessed 4 Apr. 2026.









