"Swans sing before they die - 'twere no bad thing should certain persons die before they sing"
About this Quote
Coleridge twists a pretty classical image into a knife. The “swan song” is supposed to dignify death with art: a last, pure utterance that redeems a life by turning it into music. He keeps the elegance of the proverb, then flips its moral valence. If swans only sing at the end, he implies, maybe some people would improve the world by exiting before they ever open their mouths.
The joke lands because it’s not just a burn; it’s an attack on a whole social economy of performance. “Certain persons” is deliciously vague, the kind of polite phrasing that lets a poet insult half the room while pretending manners. It gestures toward the talkers, the self-appointed sages, the public moralists, the loud mediocrities who treat speech as proof of worth. Coleridge suggests their “song” isn’t a culminating masterpiece but a nuisance: better silenced early than indulged.
Context matters: Romantic-era Britain was noisy with pamphlets, salons, lectures, and political argument, a rising marketplace where voices competed for attention. Coleridge himself was famously opinionated, a lecturer and talker of genius and excess, which gives the line an extra edge. It reads as social critique and as self-critique, a moment of cynical lucidity about how easily “expression” becomes vanity.
The intent, then, isn’t mere misanthropy. It’s a warning about the romance we attach to speech. Not everyone deserves an audience, and not every voice gets wiser with time.
The joke lands because it’s not just a burn; it’s an attack on a whole social economy of performance. “Certain persons” is deliciously vague, the kind of polite phrasing that lets a poet insult half the room while pretending manners. It gestures toward the talkers, the self-appointed sages, the public moralists, the loud mediocrities who treat speech as proof of worth. Coleridge suggests their “song” isn’t a culminating masterpiece but a nuisance: better silenced early than indulged.
Context matters: Romantic-era Britain was noisy with pamphlets, salons, lectures, and political argument, a rising marketplace where voices competed for attention. Coleridge himself was famously opinionated, a lecturer and talker of genius and excess, which gives the line an extra edge. It reads as social critique and as self-critique, a moment of cynical lucidity about how easily “expression” becomes vanity.
The intent, then, isn’t mere misanthropy. It’s a warning about the romance we attach to speech. Not everyone deserves an audience, and not every voice gets wiser with time.
Quote Details
| Topic | Dark Humor |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Samuel
Add to List











