"Take from a man his reputation for probity, and the more shrewd and clever he is, the more hated and mistrusted he becomes"
About this Quote
Strip a capable man of his reputation for probity and you don’t just wound him; you weaponize his talents against him. Cicero’s line turns on a bleak insight about how societies process competence: cleverness is only admirable when it’s morally legible. Once the public suspects dishonesty, intelligence stops reading as brilliance and starts reading as calculation. The “shrewd and clever” figure becomes uniquely terrifying because he looks like someone who can cheat you and make it look like law, policy, or common sense.
The intent is practical, even prosecutorial. Cicero isn’t writing as a dreamy ethicist; he’s a Roman statesman steeped in courts, campaigns, and factional smear. In the late Republic, reputation wasn’t a vibe, it was currency: the social credit that allowed you to speak in the Senate, win allies, command troops, or accuse rivals. Accusations of corruption or bad faith weren’t side dramas; they were political tactics with real consequence. His warning doubles as a guide for civic survival: character is not merely private virtue but the scaffolding that makes public persuasion possible.
The subtext is harsher: a community doesn’t actually trust “genius.” It trusts constraints. Probity is the reassuring signal that power will be bounded by duty. Remove that signal and the gifted individual becomes a living threat model, a person whose every skill implies a new way to exploit the system. Cicero captures the paradox of scandal: the smarter you are, the less forgiveness you get, because people assume you knew exactly what you were doing.
The intent is practical, even prosecutorial. Cicero isn’t writing as a dreamy ethicist; he’s a Roman statesman steeped in courts, campaigns, and factional smear. In the late Republic, reputation wasn’t a vibe, it was currency: the social credit that allowed you to speak in the Senate, win allies, command troops, or accuse rivals. Accusations of corruption or bad faith weren’t side dramas; they were political tactics with real consequence. His warning doubles as a guide for civic survival: character is not merely private virtue but the scaffolding that makes public persuasion possible.
The subtext is harsher: a community doesn’t actually trust “genius.” It trusts constraints. Probity is the reassuring signal that power will be bounded by duty. Remove that signal and the gifted individual becomes a living threat model, a person whose every skill implies a new way to exploit the system. Cicero captures the paradox of scandal: the smarter you are, the less forgiveness you get, because people assume you knew exactly what you were doing.
Quote Details
| Topic | Honesty & Integrity |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Cicero
Add to List








