"Talent is helpful in writing, but guts are absolutely necessary"
About this Quote
West draws a bright, almost corrective line between what looks like literary destiny and what actually gets pages written. "Talent" is the socially flattering part of authorship: the thing teachers praise, the trait you can point to in a workshop draft and say, See, it’s there. By calling it merely "helpful", she demotes the romance of the gifted writer to a nice-to-have. The word choice is surgical: helpful is what a tool is, not what a vocation runs on.
"Guts", though, is bodily. It’s courage, yes, but also endurance, appetite, and a willingness to be unseemly. West is pointing at the unglamorous engine of writing: the capacity to risk being wrong on the page, to let a sentence stand before it’s fully protected, to write into territory that might offend your circle or puncture your self-image. Guts is what you need to cut the clever paragraph because it dodges the truth; it’s what you need to keep going when the work stops rewarding you with instant affirmation.
The subtext is a quiet rebuke to meritocracy narratives about art. Talent can be inherited, noticed early, even fetishized. Guts is chosen, repeatedly, in private, with no audience. Coming from a 20th-century American novelist who lived through cultural upheaval and shifting expectations around women’s public voices, the line also reads as permission and provocation: you don’t wait to be anointed; you develop the nerve to speak. In West’s calculus, the craft isn’t gatekept by brilliance so much as by bravery.
"Guts", though, is bodily. It’s courage, yes, but also endurance, appetite, and a willingness to be unseemly. West is pointing at the unglamorous engine of writing: the capacity to risk being wrong on the page, to let a sentence stand before it’s fully protected, to write into territory that might offend your circle or puncture your self-image. Guts is what you need to cut the clever paragraph because it dodges the truth; it’s what you need to keep going when the work stops rewarding you with instant affirmation.
The subtext is a quiet rebuke to meritocracy narratives about art. Talent can be inherited, noticed early, even fetishized. Guts is chosen, repeatedly, in private, with no audience. Coming from a 20th-century American novelist who lived through cultural upheaval and shifting expectations around women’s public voices, the line also reads as permission and provocation: you don’t wait to be anointed; you develop the nerve to speak. In West’s calculus, the craft isn’t gatekept by brilliance so much as by bravery.
Quote Details
| Topic | Writing |
|---|
More Quotes by Jessamyn
Add to List
