"Tears may be dried up, but the heart - never"
About this Quote
A neat little sentimental dagger: it flatters restraint while admitting the body keeps score. Gardiner draws a bright line between public evidence and private damage. Tears are negotiable, even performative; they can be wiped away, explained away, disciplined into silence. The heart, though, is cast as the stubborn archive. You can manage appearances, she implies, but you cannot edit what you have felt.
The construction does half the work. That dash is a stage direction: pause, inhale, then the hard verdict. It mimics the moment someone tries to rally - "Ive stopped crying, so Im fine" - only to confess what the composure is hiding. In a culture where emotional control signaled virtue and class, the aphorism gives permission to grieve without the mess. It also quietly indicts the expectation that suffering should be brief, tidy, and unobtrusive.
Context matters. Writing in the late Georgian and early Victorian orbit, Gardiner sits close to a moral economy that prized sensibility but distrusted excess. This line threads that needle: it validates feeling while policing its outward signs. Theres a gendered undertone, too. Women were often allowed tears but punished for lingering pain; men were urged to dry their eyes and move on. Gardiners distinction is a rebuke to both scripts. You can be presentable and still broken, and no amount of composure proves recovery.
Its not just romantic melancholy; its a compact theory of trauma before the word was common: the visible symptom can fade, the internal wound can persist.
The construction does half the work. That dash is a stage direction: pause, inhale, then the hard verdict. It mimics the moment someone tries to rally - "Ive stopped crying, so Im fine" - only to confess what the composure is hiding. In a culture where emotional control signaled virtue and class, the aphorism gives permission to grieve without the mess. It also quietly indicts the expectation that suffering should be brief, tidy, and unobtrusive.
Context matters. Writing in the late Georgian and early Victorian orbit, Gardiner sits close to a moral economy that prized sensibility but distrusted excess. This line threads that needle: it validates feeling while policing its outward signs. Theres a gendered undertone, too. Women were often allowed tears but punished for lingering pain; men were urged to dry their eyes and move on. Gardiners distinction is a rebuke to both scripts. You can be presentable and still broken, and no amount of composure proves recovery.
Its not just romantic melancholy; its a compact theory of trauma before the word was common: the visible symptom can fade, the internal wound can persist.
Quote Details
| Topic | Heartbreak |
|---|
More Quotes by Marguerite
Add to List









