"Temperance is moderation in the things that are good and total abstinence from the things that are foul"
About this Quote
Willard’s line does a neat moral sleight of hand: it steals the language of “moderation” from the people who use it to stall reform, then redraws its borders. Temperance, in her formulation, isn’t a timid middle path; it’s a selective discipline. You don’t compromise with what she calls “foul.” You ration the good and quarantine the poison.
That division is the subtextual engine here. By splitting the world into “good” and “foul,” Willard makes abstinence feel less like denial and more like hygiene. Alcohol isn’t framed as a pleasure to be enjoyed responsibly but as contamination. And once something is contamination, the only reasonable policy is zero exposure. The sentence flatters the listener, too: it invites you to see yourself as rational and balanced (moderate with the good) while smuggling in a hardline program (total abstinence) as the logical extension of common sense.
Context matters. Willard led the Woman’s Christian Temperance Union at a time when saloons were not just places to drink but political machines, workplaces for exploitation, and, in many households, the prelude to economic ruin and domestic violence. For women with limited legal power, temperance was a lever: regulate alcohol and you regulate the social conditions that made women and children vulnerable. The rhetoric’s elegance lies in its strategic respectability. It offers an ethic that sounds calm and measured while mobilizing a movement that was anything but passive.
That division is the subtextual engine here. By splitting the world into “good” and “foul,” Willard makes abstinence feel less like denial and more like hygiene. Alcohol isn’t framed as a pleasure to be enjoyed responsibly but as contamination. And once something is contamination, the only reasonable policy is zero exposure. The sentence flatters the listener, too: it invites you to see yourself as rational and balanced (moderate with the good) while smuggling in a hardline program (total abstinence) as the logical extension of common sense.
Context matters. Willard led the Woman’s Christian Temperance Union at a time when saloons were not just places to drink but political machines, workplaces for exploitation, and, in many households, the prelude to economic ruin and domestic violence. For women with limited legal power, temperance was a lever: regulate alcohol and you regulate the social conditions that made women and children vulnerable. The rhetoric’s elegance lies in its strategic respectability. It offers an ethic that sounds calm and measured while mobilizing a movement that was anything but passive.
Quote Details
| Topic | Self-Discipline |
|---|
More Quotes by Frances
Add to List







