"Ten thousand difficulties do not make one doubt"
About this Quote
Newman is drawing a hard line between friction and fracture. "Ten thousand difficulties" stacks the deck with a cartoonishly large number, then refuses to let quantity do the moral work of proof. The rhetoric is deliberately muscular: difficulties can be endless, noisy, even persuasive in the moment, but they are not the same species as doubt. He’s trying to rescue faith from the common modern bargain that treats unanswered questions as automatic defeaters.
The intent is pastoral and strategic. As a 19th-century Anglican-turned-Catholic intellectual, Newman lived amid Darwin’s aftershocks, higher criticism, and a growing prestige culture around skepticism. For many Victorians, religion was being cross-examined by science, history, and the new social authority of "rational" discourse. Newman answers by reframing the courtroom. Difficulties are the normal weather of serious belief - intellectual knots, emotional dry spells, apparent contradictions. Doubt is the deeper shift of allegiance, a movement of the will and imagination away from assent.
Subtext: don’t confuse mental strain with spiritual dishonesty. Newman is also quietly rebuking a certain kind of cleverness that collects objections like trophies, mistaking accumulation for insight. The line carries an implicit psychology: humans rarely live by airtight demonstrations; we navigate by converging probabilities, loyalties, and lived experience. If certainty depended on the elimination of all problems, no one could hold any conviction at all - religious, political, or personal.
It’s a sentence built to steady a reader: difficulties can be counted; doubt, for Newman, is chosen.
The intent is pastoral and strategic. As a 19th-century Anglican-turned-Catholic intellectual, Newman lived amid Darwin’s aftershocks, higher criticism, and a growing prestige culture around skepticism. For many Victorians, religion was being cross-examined by science, history, and the new social authority of "rational" discourse. Newman answers by reframing the courtroom. Difficulties are the normal weather of serious belief - intellectual knots, emotional dry spells, apparent contradictions. Doubt is the deeper shift of allegiance, a movement of the will and imagination away from assent.
Subtext: don’t confuse mental strain with spiritual dishonesty. Newman is also quietly rebuking a certain kind of cleverness that collects objections like trophies, mistaking accumulation for insight. The line carries an implicit psychology: humans rarely live by airtight demonstrations; we navigate by converging probabilities, loyalties, and lived experience. If certainty depended on the elimination of all problems, no one could hold any conviction at all - religious, political, or personal.
It’s a sentence built to steady a reader: difficulties can be counted; doubt, for Newman, is chosen.
Quote Details
| Topic | Faith |
|---|
More Quotes by John
Add to List








