"Textbook publishers don't even bother to advertise at their conventions"
About this Quote
There’s a whole world of indictment packed into that offhand shrug: “Textbook publishers don’t even bother to advertise at their conventions.” Brimelow frames it like a throwaway observation, but the bite is in what it implies about power and capture. If the people who supposedly “represent” educators are so predictable, so institutionally aligned, that publishers can skip the persuasion step, then the market has ossified into a cozy pipeline. Advertising is what you do when you need to compete for attention; not advertising suggests you already own the room.
The line works because it’s an accusation disguised as a detail. Brimelow doesn’t argue that teacher or academic conventions are corrupt; he narrates a behavioral tell that invites the reader to connect the dots. The subtext is a critique of the education-policy ecosystem as self-referential and insulated, where decisions about curricula and standards are made inside a closed circuit of administrators, committees, and vendors. Publishers aren’t courting teachers as consumers; they’re treating the convention as a formality, a ritual of an industry that has settled into its relationships.
Context matters, too. The late-20th-century rise of “ed reform” reporting, culture-war fights over curricula, and growing skepticism about institutional incentives all make this kind of line land. It’s pointed, a little cynical, and journalistic in the Mencken-ish sense: expose the machinery, don’t sermonize. The real target isn’t advertising budgets; it’s the idea that public-facing deliberation is often theater when the supply chain is already locked in.
The line works because it’s an accusation disguised as a detail. Brimelow doesn’t argue that teacher or academic conventions are corrupt; he narrates a behavioral tell that invites the reader to connect the dots. The subtext is a critique of the education-policy ecosystem as self-referential and insulated, where decisions about curricula and standards are made inside a closed circuit of administrators, committees, and vendors. Publishers aren’t courting teachers as consumers; they’re treating the convention as a formality, a ritual of an industry that has settled into its relationships.
Context matters, too. The late-20th-century rise of “ed reform” reporting, culture-war fights over curricula, and growing skepticism about institutional incentives all make this kind of line land. It’s pointed, a little cynical, and journalistic in the Mencken-ish sense: expose the machinery, don’t sermonize. The real target isn’t advertising budgets; it’s the idea that public-facing deliberation is often theater when the supply chain is already locked in.
Quote Details
| Topic | Witty One-Liners |
|---|
More Quotes by Peter
Add to List


