"That element of surprise is what I look for when I am writing. It is my way of judging what I am doing - which is never an easy thing to do"
About this Quote
Naipaul’s “element of surprise” isn’t a cute writerly preference; it’s a private lie detector. He’s talking about a craft standard that refuses the comfort of competence. If the sentence arrives exactly as planned, it’s suspect. Surprise becomes evidence that the work has outrun the author’s preconceptions, that it has stumbled into truth rather than recited a position.
The subtext is characteristically Naipaul: skeptical of easy sincerity, allergic to moral posing, wary of the writer as benevolent tour guide. He’s admitting that judging one’s own work is “never an easy thing” because the self is the most compromised critic in the room. Surprise is a workaround for ego. It’s also a discipline: you write until something happens on the page that you didn’t know you knew. For Naipaul, whose fiction and nonfiction circle the psychic wreckage of empire, displacement, and ambition, that’s not just aesthetic. It’s ethical. Predictable prose can turn other people’s lives into scenery; surprise can puncture the writer’s complacency and force a closer look.
Context matters because Naipaul’s reputation is inseparable from his severity: the cool gaze, the refusal to flatter nations or narratives, the impatience with received pieties. This remark frames that severity as method rather than mood. He isn’t chasing plot twists; he’s chasing the moment the language resists him, when the material pushes back. In that friction, he finds a measure of honesty - not the warm kind, but the kind that survives scrutiny.
The subtext is characteristically Naipaul: skeptical of easy sincerity, allergic to moral posing, wary of the writer as benevolent tour guide. He’s admitting that judging one’s own work is “never an easy thing” because the self is the most compromised critic in the room. Surprise is a workaround for ego. It’s also a discipline: you write until something happens on the page that you didn’t know you knew. For Naipaul, whose fiction and nonfiction circle the psychic wreckage of empire, displacement, and ambition, that’s not just aesthetic. It’s ethical. Predictable prose can turn other people’s lives into scenery; surprise can puncture the writer’s complacency and force a closer look.
Context matters because Naipaul’s reputation is inseparable from his severity: the cool gaze, the refusal to flatter nations or narratives, the impatience with received pieties. This remark frames that severity as method rather than mood. He isn’t chasing plot twists; he’s chasing the moment the language resists him, when the material pushes back. In that friction, he finds a measure of honesty - not the warm kind, but the kind that survives scrutiny.
Quote Details
| Topic | Writing |
|---|
More Quotes by S. Naipaul
Add to List
