"That is simply that Marxism has been tremendously fashionable in our time, so it has infected a very large number of major institutions in many countries of the world. So I suppose that we shouldn't be too surprised that it should infect the church as well"
About this Quote
Fashion is doing the heavy lifting here. Kirkpatrick doesn’t argue Marxism down so much as she frames it as a contagion: “tremendously fashionable,” then “infected,” then the final punchline, the church. The rhetoric is clinical and faintly disdainful, the way you’d talk about a virus moving through crowded institutions. By choosing that metaphor, she sidesteps the possibility that Marxism might have intellectual or moral appeal; it becomes an external agent, not a set of ideas people adopt for reasons. That’s the intent: to delegitimize by pathologizing.
The subtext is a warning about elite capture. “Major institutions” is a broad net that quietly includes universities, media, bureaucracies, and international bodies, the very infrastructure that shapes how a society thinks. “Many countries of the world” adds geopolitical scale, implying a coordinated, era-defining drift. The church is strategically last because it’s supposed to be the holdout: a moral institution imagined as insulated from ideological fads. If even that sanctuary is compromised, then nothing is safe from the zeitgeist.
Context matters: Kirkpatrick was a Cold War diplomat and a signature hawk of the Reagan era, attentive to how ideology travels through institutions and legitimizes political movements. Read against debates over liberation theology and left-leaning clerical activism, the line is less about theology than about authority. She’s policing boundaries: faith should not provide moral cover for revolutionary politics. The sly, almost conversational “we shouldn’t be too surprised” invites the reader to share her skepticism, turning alarm into common sense.
The subtext is a warning about elite capture. “Major institutions” is a broad net that quietly includes universities, media, bureaucracies, and international bodies, the very infrastructure that shapes how a society thinks. “Many countries of the world” adds geopolitical scale, implying a coordinated, era-defining drift. The church is strategically last because it’s supposed to be the holdout: a moral institution imagined as insulated from ideological fads. If even that sanctuary is compromised, then nothing is safe from the zeitgeist.
Context matters: Kirkpatrick was a Cold War diplomat and a signature hawk of the Reagan era, attentive to how ideology travels through institutions and legitimizes political movements. Read against debates over liberation theology and left-leaning clerical activism, the line is less about theology than about authority. She’s policing boundaries: faith should not provide moral cover for revolutionary politics. The sly, almost conversational “we shouldn’t be too surprised” invites the reader to share her skepticism, turning alarm into common sense.
Quote Details
| Topic | Faith |
|---|
More Quotes by Jeane
Add to List




