"That man is a creature who needs order yet yearns for change is the creative contradiction at the heart of the laws which structure his conformity and define his deviancy"
About this Quote
Adler’s line reads like a clean autopsy of modern social life: we’re built to crave rules, then we chafe against them, and out of that friction comes both culture and crime. As an educator (and, in Adler’s broader work, a criminologist), she’s not moralizing about “bad people.” She’s reframing deviancy as a structural byproduct of the same legal order that claims to eradicate it. The punch is in “creative contradiction.” Deviance isn’t merely failure; it’s innovation under pressure, a way societies test their own boundaries and, sometimes, update them.
The subtext is a quiet indictment of how institutions talk about conformity. “Order” sounds neutral, even benevolent, but Adler reminds us it’s engineered: laws “structure” conformity, meaning they manufacture normalcy as much as they reflect it. That also means deviancy is defined, not discovered. The deviant is often the person who collides with a rule someone else had the power to write, enforce, and narrate.
Contextually, this sits comfortably in late-20th-century skepticism toward simple crime-and-punishment stories. It echoes labeling theory and other sociological approaches that treat law as a social technology: it organizes behavior, distributes stigma, and draws the line between acceptable change (entrepreneurship, protest, art) and punishable change (transgression, disorder). Adler’s intent is to make the reader uneasy with easy binaries. If the human animal “yearns for change,” then a society that worships order will always be busy producing its own outsiders.
The subtext is a quiet indictment of how institutions talk about conformity. “Order” sounds neutral, even benevolent, but Adler reminds us it’s engineered: laws “structure” conformity, meaning they manufacture normalcy as much as they reflect it. That also means deviancy is defined, not discovered. The deviant is often the person who collides with a rule someone else had the power to write, enforce, and narrate.
Contextually, this sits comfortably in late-20th-century skepticism toward simple crime-and-punishment stories. It echoes labeling theory and other sociological approaches that treat law as a social technology: it organizes behavior, distributes stigma, and draws the line between acceptable change (entrepreneurship, protest, art) and punishable change (transgression, disorder). Adler’s intent is to make the reader uneasy with easy binaries. If the human animal “yearns for change,” then a society that worships order will always be busy producing its own outsiders.
Quote Details
| Topic | Deep |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Freda
Add to List










