"That we are to stand by the President right or wrong is not only unpatriotic and servile, but is morally treasonable to the American public"
About this Quote
The statement presents a forceful argument against the concept of unconditional allegiance to a leader, specifically the President. Loyalty, it suggests, is not inherently virtuous if it disregards ethical considerations or the broader public good. To stand by the President “right or wrong” implies a sort of blind obedience, a suspension of one’s moral compass in favor of loyalty to an individual in power. Such obedience, referred to here as unpatriotic, undermines the very foundations of democratic society, which is built on the principle of holding leaders accountable.
Patriotism is defined not by submission to authority, but by commitment to the values that underpin the nation, liberty, justice, and accountability. Encouraging people to support any leader regardless of their actions corrupts the concept of citizenship and reduces the role of the public to mere servitude. The use of “servile” stresses the loss of self-respect and agency in such blind loyalty, implying a kind of willful subordination unbecoming of free citizens.
Going further, the words “morally treasonable”, a strong condemnation, suggest that unconditional support can amount to a betrayal not just of ideals, but of the actual wellbeing of society. Treason is usually understood as an act against the state; here, it is redefined as an act against the public morality and collective conscience. It is not the questioning of leadership that endangers society, but the failure to question, the surrender of judgment, and the silencing of dissent.
The statement urges citizens to assume a higher obligation: to weigh the actions of their leaders, to demand integrity, and to resist the normalization of wrongdoing. Bluntly rejecting the idea of “my country, right or wrong” when applied to political figures, the text makes a case for active, engaged citizenship as the only morally defensible form of patriotism.
Patriotism is defined not by submission to authority, but by commitment to the values that underpin the nation, liberty, justice, and accountability. Encouraging people to support any leader regardless of their actions corrupts the concept of citizenship and reduces the role of the public to mere servitude. The use of “servile” stresses the loss of self-respect and agency in such blind loyalty, implying a kind of willful subordination unbecoming of free citizens.
Going further, the words “morally treasonable”, a strong condemnation, suggest that unconditional support can amount to a betrayal not just of ideals, but of the actual wellbeing of society. Treason is usually understood as an act against the state; here, it is redefined as an act against the public morality and collective conscience. It is not the questioning of leadership that endangers society, but the failure to question, the surrender of judgment, and the silencing of dissent.
The statement urges citizens to assume a higher obligation: to weigh the actions of their leaders, to demand integrity, and to resist the normalization of wrongdoing. Bluntly rejecting the idea of “my country, right or wrong” when applied to political figures, the text makes a case for active, engaged citizenship as the only morally defensible form of patriotism.
Quote Details
| Topic | Justice |
|---|---|
| Source | Quote commonly attributed to Theodore Roosevelt; see Wikiquote entry 'Theodore Roosevelt' for attribution. |
More Quotes by Charlie
Add to List






