"That which is unjust can really profit no one; that which is just can really harm no one"
About this Quote
A Victorian-era economist making a moral claim this blunt is picking a fight with the grown-up excuse of his age: that markets are amoral machines and “profit” is its own alibi. Henry George’s line is a pressure test. It dares you to define profit beyond the quarterly ledger, beyond the private windfall, and measure it against social cost. If an arrangement is unjust, any gains it produces are counterfeit: they depend on coercion, monopoly, or rigged access, so they rot the system that supposedly made them possible. Someone pays. It just isn’t always the person cashing the check.
The subtext is Georgist to the core. Writing in a Gilded Age of rail barons, land speculation, and urban poverty, George argued that poverty wasn’t a natural side effect of progress; it was engineered through control of land and the unearned rents extracted from it. In that context, “unjust” doesn’t mean vaguely unkind. It points at structural advantages that let a few harvest wealth created by everyone else. “Profit no one” is a long-view claim: concentrated gains metastasize into instability, resentment, corruption, and wasted human potential.
The second clause flips the usual fear that fairness is expensive. George insists justice is not a sacrifice but a stabilizer. It can threaten privileges and still “harm no one” in the only sense that counts: it doesn’t diminish legitimate well-being, it just withdraws illegitimate claims. The line works because it reframes reform from charity to accounting - a demand to stop mistaking extraction for prosperity.
The subtext is Georgist to the core. Writing in a Gilded Age of rail barons, land speculation, and urban poverty, George argued that poverty wasn’t a natural side effect of progress; it was engineered through control of land and the unearned rents extracted from it. In that context, “unjust” doesn’t mean vaguely unkind. It points at structural advantages that let a few harvest wealth created by everyone else. “Profit no one” is a long-view claim: concentrated gains metastasize into instability, resentment, corruption, and wasted human potential.
The second clause flips the usual fear that fairness is expensive. George insists justice is not a sacrifice but a stabilizer. It can threaten privileges and still “harm no one” in the only sense that counts: it doesn’t diminish legitimate well-being, it just withdraws illegitimate claims. The line works because it reframes reform from charity to accounting - a demand to stop mistaking extraction for prosperity.
Quote Details
| Topic | Justice |
|---|
More Quotes by Henry
Add to List



