"The achievements which society rewards are won at the cost of diminution of personality"
About this Quote
Progress, Jowett suggests, is often a trade: the shiny prizes society hands out are paid for with something private, irregular, and hard to monetize. The phrase "society rewards" is doing quiet violence here. It implies an external tribunal with clear rules, and it hints that the rules are less about excellence than about legibility. To be rewarded is to be recognized; to be recognized is to be made readable. That demand for readability is where "diminution of personality" bites.
Jowett, a Victorian theologian and Master of Balliol, watched an era professionalize belief, scholarship, and public life. Institutions were tightening their standards, consolidating power, and building reputations on decorum. In that world, achievement wasn’t just producing knowledge or virtue; it was performing the right kind of self. Ambition required a narrowing: smoothing out oddness, disciplining desire, adopting the accent of consensus. You win by becoming a type.
The subtext carries a moral warning that fits a theologian: what looks like success can be a form of spiritual loss. Not sin in the lurid sense, but erosion - the slow replacement of inner integrity with external approval. "Cost" is the pivot: it frames conformity as a transaction, not a destiny. Jowett isn’t romanticizing failure; he’s interrogating the price of the victory lap. The line lands because it refuses the comforting story that recognition is proof of wholeness. It can be proof of careful self-editing.
Jowett, a Victorian theologian and Master of Balliol, watched an era professionalize belief, scholarship, and public life. Institutions were tightening their standards, consolidating power, and building reputations on decorum. In that world, achievement wasn’t just producing knowledge or virtue; it was performing the right kind of self. Ambition required a narrowing: smoothing out oddness, disciplining desire, adopting the accent of consensus. You win by becoming a type.
The subtext carries a moral warning that fits a theologian: what looks like success can be a form of spiritual loss. Not sin in the lurid sense, but erosion - the slow replacement of inner integrity with external approval. "Cost" is the pivot: it frames conformity as a transaction, not a destiny. Jowett isn’t romanticizing failure; he’s interrogating the price of the victory lap. The line lands because it refuses the comforting story that recognition is proof of wholeness. It can be proof of careful self-editing.
Quote Details
| Topic | Wisdom |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Benjamin
Add to List










