"The basic notion was the idea that the loudspeaker should have a voice which was unique and not just an instrument of reproduction, but an instrument unto itself"
About this Quote
The intent is practical and philosophical at once. Practically, it licenses the composer/engineer to design systems where feedback, distortion, resonance, and spatial projection aren’t defects to be minimized but materials to be shaped. Philosophically, it relocates authorship: the “voice” isn’t only in the score or the player’s touch, but in the behavior of an electro-acoustic body. A speaker “unto itself” implies temperament. It can surprise you, refuse you, misbehave in ways that become the piece.
Subtextually, Tudor is also arguing against a museum-like relationship to sound, where the goal is to preserve an original somewhere else (a singer in a studio, an orchestra in a hall). His world is closer to sculpture than to documentation: sound as something built, situated, and contingent on the room, the gear, and the moment.
Context matters: postwar experimental music, the Cage orbit, early electronic performance, and an era when “good sound” meant disappearing hardware. Tudor flips that. He asks us to hear the machine not as a delivery system, but as a collaborator with its own grain, its own accent, its own agency.
Quote Details
| Topic | Music |
|---|---|
| Source | Verified source: I smile when the sound is singing through the space (David Tudor, 1988)
Evidence: The basic notion, which is a technical one, was the idea that the loudspeaker should have a voice which was unique and not just an instrument of reproduction, but an instrument unto itself. (Rainforest IV section; page number not available in the online transcript). The quote appears in the primary-source interview 'I smile when the sound is singing through the space,' conducted by Teddy Hultberg in Dusseldorf on May 17–18, 1988. In the transcript, Tudor says this while discussing 'Rainforest IV.' The commonly circulated version omits the opening clause 'which is a technical one.' I did not find evidence that this exact wording was published earlier than this 1988 interview. The interview is presented on the David Tudor website and is widely cited by later scholarly sources as 'David Tudor and Teddy Hultberg, Dusseldorf, May 17–18, 1988.' Other candidates (1) A Time for Choosing (Ronald Reagan) primary60.0% Song: "A Time for Choosing" by Ronald Reagan |
| Cite |
Citation Formats
APA Style (7th ed.)
Tudor, David. (2026, March 14). The basic notion was the idea that the loudspeaker should have a voice which was unique and not just an instrument of reproduction, but an instrument unto itself. FixQuotes. https://fixquotes.com/quotes/the-basic-notion-was-the-idea-that-the-126083/
Chicago Style
Tudor, David. "The basic notion was the idea that the loudspeaker should have a voice which was unique and not just an instrument of reproduction, but an instrument unto itself." FixQuotes. March 14, 2026. https://fixquotes.com/quotes/the-basic-notion-was-the-idea-that-the-126083/.
MLA Style (9th ed.)
"The basic notion was the idea that the loudspeaker should have a voice which was unique and not just an instrument of reproduction, but an instrument unto itself." FixQuotes, 14 Mar. 2026, https://fixquotes.com/quotes/the-basic-notion-was-the-idea-that-the-126083/. Accessed 28 Mar. 2026.



