"The best way I know of to win an argument is to start by being in the right"

Lord Hailsham’s assertion, "The best way I know of to win an argument is to start by being in the right", reflects a profound truth about reasoning, persuasion, and integrity. Instead of emphasizing rhetorical skill, manipulation, or clever tactics, Hailsham places ultimate importance on the substance of one’s position. He implies that the foundation of any persuasive argument lies not in how convincingly it is presented, but whether it is grounded in truth, facts, or moral correctness.

Winning arguments for the sake of pride or social status can be tempting, especially in environments where debate is valued as intellectual prowess. However, hollow victories achieved through sophistry or sleight of hand rarely withstand scrutiny and may even erode trust over time. Hailsham draws attention to the enduring power of being substantively correct. Arguments based on sound logic, accurate evidence, and genuine conviction tend to withstand challenges and resonate more deeply with listeners. Even if one’s oratory skills are not exemplary, being "in the right" provides a foundation that cannot easily be undermined.

Furthermore, this perspective encourages humility and intellectual honesty. Before entering into disagreement, one must engage in self-examination: Have I researched thoroughly? Is my understanding accurate? Am I open to opposing views or evidence that might shift my stance? Such questions foster a mindset less concerned with superficial victory than with real understanding. This approach also upholds the ethical dimension of argument. Persuasion that originates in honesty and truth-seeking is inherently more admirable and ultimately more effective in engendering respect and influencing others, even if immediate "victory" is elusive.

Finally, Hailsham’s view subtly suggests that the best arguments are those that educate, illuminate, or correct, rather than merely defeat. By emphasizing being "in the right", he advocates for debates that contribute to collective wisdom and progress, rather than ego or point-scoring.