"The best way to get a bad law repealed is to enforce it strictly"
About this Quote
Lincoln’s line is a pressure test disguised as a principle: if a law is truly “bad,” the fastest way to expose it is not to quietly ignore it, but to apply it so faithfully that its cruelty, absurdity, or impracticality becomes impossible to sentimentalize. Strict enforcement turns a flawed rule from an abstract idea into lived experience. It forces everyone, especially comfortable bystanders, to pay the full moral and social price of what they’ve tolerated on paper.
The intent isn’t legalistic; it’s political. Lincoln is pointing to a grim mechanism of democracy: repeal rarely comes from tidy debate. It comes when a policy generates enough public friction that maintaining it becomes costlier than changing it. Half-enforcement lets a bad law limp along indefinitely, protected by ambiguity and selective application. Full enforcement strips away the wiggle room that allows elites to claim the law “isn’t really hurting anyone,” while still weaponizing it when convenient.
The subtext carries an implicit warning about legitimacy. A state that refuses to enforce its own statutes invites cynicism and arbitrary power; a state that enforces unjust statutes invites backlash and reform. Lincoln, governing amid existential conflict, understood that law isn’t just a set of rules but a claim to authority. By insisting on strictness, he’s betting that the public, confronted with the law’s real consequences, will choose repeal rather than normalize injustice. It’s moral suasion, but with the blunt instrument of procedure.
The intent isn’t legalistic; it’s political. Lincoln is pointing to a grim mechanism of democracy: repeal rarely comes from tidy debate. It comes when a policy generates enough public friction that maintaining it becomes costlier than changing it. Half-enforcement lets a bad law limp along indefinitely, protected by ambiguity and selective application. Full enforcement strips away the wiggle room that allows elites to claim the law “isn’t really hurting anyone,” while still weaponizing it when convenient.
The subtext carries an implicit warning about legitimacy. A state that refuses to enforce its own statutes invites cynicism and arbitrary power; a state that enforces unjust statutes invites backlash and reform. Lincoln, governing amid existential conflict, understood that law isn’t just a set of rules but a claim to authority. By insisting on strictness, he’s betting that the public, confronted with the law’s real consequences, will choose repeal rather than normalize injustice. It’s moral suasion, but with the blunt instrument of procedure.
Quote Details
| Topic | Justice |
|---|---|
| Source | Later attribution: Quote Junkie (Hagopian Institute, 2008) modern compilationISBN: 9781438245188 · ID: d4Do5xvqGwgC
Evidence: ... Abraham Lincoln The ballot is stronger than the bullet . Abraham Lincoln The best way to get a bad law repealed is to enforce it strictly . Abraham Lincoln The time comes upon every public man when it is best for him to keep his lips closed ... Other candidates (1) Abraham Lincoln (Abraham Lincoln) compilation40.0% they meant simply to declare the right so that the enforcement of it might follo |
More Quotes by Abraham
Add to List




