"The church also does not condone a broken immigration system in the U.S., one that too easily can lead to the exploitation, abuse and even death of immigrants"
About this Quote
Mahony’s line is engineered to do two things at once: defend the church’s moral credibility while yanking immigration out of the realm of “policy debate” and into the realm of preventable harm. The key move is his opening concession - “The church also does not condone” - which sounds measured, even diplomatic, but functions like a preemptive rebuttal. It anticipates the familiar accusation that religious leaders only pipe up to demand compassion from others while ignoring the rule-of-law frame. He answers by conceding the premise (systems matter) and then redefining what the system is actually producing.
Calling it “broken” is political shorthand, but Mahony immediately specifies the break: not bureaucratic inefficiency, but a structure “that too easily can lead” to exploitation and death. That phrase “too easily” is doing quiet heavy lifting. It suggests inevitability without claiming direct intent, indicting the system as a machine that reliably generates victims even when no single actor admits malice. “Exploitation, abuse and even death” escalates like a prosecutor’s charge sheet, widening the moral aperture from economic vulnerability to bodily peril.
The subtext is pastoral and strategic: immigrants aren’t merely lawbreakers or strangers; they are people pushed into predatory shadows by design. In the post-1990s climate of tightened borders and rising detention, the statement aligns Catholic social teaching with a distinctly American critique: when lawful pathways are scarce, illegality becomes a market, and human beings become inventory. Mahony isn’t asking for sentiment; he’s arguing that cruelty is a predictable output, and complicity begins at the level of public architecture.
Calling it “broken” is political shorthand, but Mahony immediately specifies the break: not bureaucratic inefficiency, but a structure “that too easily can lead” to exploitation and death. That phrase “too easily” is doing quiet heavy lifting. It suggests inevitability without claiming direct intent, indicting the system as a machine that reliably generates victims even when no single actor admits malice. “Exploitation, abuse and even death” escalates like a prosecutor’s charge sheet, widening the moral aperture from economic vulnerability to bodily peril.
The subtext is pastoral and strategic: immigrants aren’t merely lawbreakers or strangers; they are people pushed into predatory shadows by design. In the post-1990s climate of tightened borders and rising detention, the statement aligns Catholic social teaching with a distinctly American critique: when lawful pathways are scarce, illegality becomes a market, and human beings become inventory. Mahony isn’t asking for sentiment; he’s arguing that cruelty is a predictable output, and complicity begins at the level of public architecture.
Quote Details
| Topic | Human Rights |
|---|
More Quotes by Roger
Add to List
