"The Church does not pretend to be scientists. It teaches based upon what science tells it"
About this Quote
Mara’s line is a piece of civic-era damage control: a businessman’s tidy assurance that the Church isn’t trying to run the lab, just read the lab report. The phrasing matters. “Does not pretend” is a reputational move, not a theological one; it concedes the modern prestige of science while implying that any conflict is really about perception and overreach. It’s also classic managerial rhetoric: define the organization’s “core competency,” then reassure stakeholders that you’re staying in your lane.
The subtext is triangulation. By saying the Church “teaches based upon what science tells it,” Mara frames doctrine as downstream of empirical discovery, borrowing science’s authority to shore up faith’s credibility. That’s a subtle inversion of the usual critique that religion cherry-picks data: he implies receptivity, even humility, without granting science the final word on meaning. “Based upon” does a lot of work here; it’s elastic enough to suggest alignment while leaving room for selective interpretation, moral framing, or outright boundary-setting when the data becomes inconvenient.
Contextually, a mid-to-late 20th century American Catholic audience was living through public disputes over evolution, contraception, and later abortion and bioethics, all amplified by mass media. Mara’s posture fits that moment: reassure modern professionals that faith isn’t anti-modern, while keeping the Church’s teaching authority intact. It’s less a scientific thesis than a branding statement about compatibility - and who gets to narrate it.
The subtext is triangulation. By saying the Church “teaches based upon what science tells it,” Mara frames doctrine as downstream of empirical discovery, borrowing science’s authority to shore up faith’s credibility. That’s a subtle inversion of the usual critique that religion cherry-picks data: he implies receptivity, even humility, without granting science the final word on meaning. “Based upon” does a lot of work here; it’s elastic enough to suggest alignment while leaving room for selective interpretation, moral framing, or outright boundary-setting when the data becomes inconvenient.
Contextually, a mid-to-late 20th century American Catholic audience was living through public disputes over evolution, contraception, and later abortion and bioethics, all amplified by mass media. Mara’s posture fits that moment: reassure modern professionals that faith isn’t anti-modern, while keeping the Church’s teaching authority intact. It’s less a scientific thesis than a branding statement about compatibility - and who gets to narrate it.
Quote Details
| Topic | Science |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Wellington
Add to List






