"The church saves sinners, but science seeks to stop their manufacture"
About this Quote
Hubbard’s line lands like a punchy factory metaphor smuggled into a moral argument. “Saves sinners” frames the church as an institution built for triage: people arrive already broken, already guilty, and the system offers absolution as aftercare. Then he swivels to “manufacture,” a word that drips with industrial-era suspicion. Sin isn’t just a personal failing in this worldview; it’s a product of conditions - poverty, ignorance, alcoholism, disease, unsafe work, bad housing - churned out at scale. The subtext is unmistakably Progressive: stop romanticizing rescue missions and start fixing the machinery that keeps producing misery.
The sentence works because it sets up a neat opposition while quietly indicting both sides. The church gets credit for compassion but is boxed into a reactive role, managing consequences rather than causes. Science, meanwhile, is cast as preventative, almost hygienic: identify inputs, adjust the system, reduce output. It’s a flattering pitch for modern expertise, but Hubbard’s phrasing also hints at a coldness in the scientific impulse - “stop” and “manufacture” reduce moral life to process engineering. Prevention can sound like control.
Context matters. Hubbard wrote in an America electrified by new technologies, public health reforms, and faith in efficiency, while religious institutions still dominated moral language. The line isn’t anti-church so much as pro-upstream thinking: a challenge to charity-as-spectacle and a bet that knowledge, policy, and reform can shrink the pipeline of “sinners” before salvation has to step in.
The sentence works because it sets up a neat opposition while quietly indicting both sides. The church gets credit for compassion but is boxed into a reactive role, managing consequences rather than causes. Science, meanwhile, is cast as preventative, almost hygienic: identify inputs, adjust the system, reduce output. It’s a flattering pitch for modern expertise, but Hubbard’s phrasing also hints at a coldness in the scientific impulse - “stop” and “manufacture” reduce moral life to process engineering. Prevention can sound like control.
Context matters. Hubbard wrote in an America electrified by new technologies, public health reforms, and faith in efficiency, while religious institutions still dominated moral language. The line isn’t anti-church so much as pro-upstream thinking: a challenge to charity-as-spectacle and a bet that knowledge, policy, and reform can shrink the pipeline of “sinners” before salvation has to step in.
Quote Details
| Topic | Witty One-Liners |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Elbert
Add to List


