"The Columbia is lost, but the dreams that inspired its crew remain with us"
About this Quote
Grief is doing double duty here: it mourns seven lives while immediately drafting them into a national narrative. Cheney's line lands in the wake of the 2003 Space Shuttle Columbia disaster, when the country needed an explanation sturdy enough to hold both sorrow and purpose. The first clause is blunt, almost clinical: "The Columbia is lost". No metaphors, no escape hatches. It acknowledges irrevocable failure in the most compressed way possible, giving the public permission to feel the shock without arguing about causes, budgets, or accountability.
Then the pivot: "but the dreams that inspired its crew remain with us". The conjunction is the lever. It moves the focus from institutional loss (a government spacecraft, a program under scrutiny) to something softer and harder to dispute: "dreams". That word is strategically nontechnical. It sidesteps engineering questions and political liability by translating a complex, expensive, contested enterprise into an American moral asset: aspiration. The crew becomes less a set of individuals with specific biographies than vessels for an idea, and the public becomes the inheritor of that idea. "Remain with us" is the quiet command; it asks citizens to carry forward the meaning, which in practice often means continued support for NASA and for a broader posture of national resolve.
Coming from a vice president associated with hard power and wartime rhetoric, the sentence also functions as reputational calibration: a statesmanly tenderness that frames the tragedy as sacrifice in service of a shared future, not a preventable misstep. The result is consoling, persuasive, and politically useful all at once.
Then the pivot: "but the dreams that inspired its crew remain with us". The conjunction is the lever. It moves the focus from institutional loss (a government spacecraft, a program under scrutiny) to something softer and harder to dispute: "dreams". That word is strategically nontechnical. It sidesteps engineering questions and political liability by translating a complex, expensive, contested enterprise into an American moral asset: aspiration. The crew becomes less a set of individuals with specific biographies than vessels for an idea, and the public becomes the inheritor of that idea. "Remain with us" is the quiet command; it asks citizens to carry forward the meaning, which in practice often means continued support for NASA and for a broader posture of national resolve.
Coming from a vice president associated with hard power and wartime rhetoric, the sentence also functions as reputational calibration: a statesmanly tenderness that frames the tragedy as sacrifice in service of a shared future, not a preventable misstep. The result is consoling, persuasive, and politically useful all at once.
Quote Details
| Topic | Legacy & Remembrance |
|---|
More Quotes by Dick
Add to List



