"The consequence was, that the most sudden and visible good effects were perceived from the use of oranges and lemons; one of those who had taken them, being at the end of 6 days fit for duty"
About this Quote
A clinical sentence with a quiet fuse: Lind is smuggling a revolution into the plainest prose possible. “The consequence was” sounds like bookkeeping, yet it marks a break from centuries of maritime fatalism in which scurvy was treated as weather - inevitable, cruel, and only vaguely understood. By anchoring his claim in “sudden and visible good effects,” Lind isn’t just reporting improvement; he’s advertising a new standard of proof. You can see it. You can count the days. You can watch a sailor go from wrecked body to “fit for duty” in under a week.
The intent is practical, almost military: not to dazzle, but to persuade commanders, surgeons, and bureaucrats who speak the language of readiness. “Fit for duty” is the real punchline. Health is framed as operational capacity, which is exactly how an empire with global shipping lanes would be convinced. Lind’s science doesn’t arrive as abstract theory; it arrives as restored labor.
The subtext is also a rebuke to medical fashion. Mid-18th-century treatments for scurvy were a grab bag of acids, tonics, and folklore. Lind’s emphasis on immediacy (“at the end of 6 days”) undercuts the argument that recovery is coincidence or morale. He’s implicitly saying: stop romanticizing suffering at sea; stop treating disease as a mystery with a patron saint. Here is a repeatable intervention.
Context makes the understatement sharper. This is early controlled experimentation in a world that still trusted authority over evidence. Lind writes like a man who knows the facts will win - if he keeps the rhetoric austere enough to slip past ego, tradition, and the Navy’s inertia.
The intent is practical, almost military: not to dazzle, but to persuade commanders, surgeons, and bureaucrats who speak the language of readiness. “Fit for duty” is the real punchline. Health is framed as operational capacity, which is exactly how an empire with global shipping lanes would be convinced. Lind’s science doesn’t arrive as abstract theory; it arrives as restored labor.
The subtext is also a rebuke to medical fashion. Mid-18th-century treatments for scurvy were a grab bag of acids, tonics, and folklore. Lind’s emphasis on immediacy (“at the end of 6 days”) undercuts the argument that recovery is coincidence or morale. He’s implicitly saying: stop romanticizing suffering at sea; stop treating disease as a mystery with a patron saint. Here is a repeatable intervention.
Context makes the understatement sharper. This is early controlled experimentation in a world that still trusted authority over evidence. Lind writes like a man who knows the facts will win - if he keeps the rhetoric austere enough to slip past ego, tradition, and the Navy’s inertia.
Quote Details
| Topic | Health |
|---|---|
| Source | James Lind, A Treatise of the Scurvy (1753). Passage reporting Lind's clinical trial that oranges and lemons produced rapid improvement—one patient "at the end of 6 days fit for duty". |
More Quotes by James
Add to List
