"The Cross is the approbation of our existence, not in words, but in an act so completely radical that it caused God to become flesh and pierced this flesh to the quick; that, to God, it was worth the death of his incarnate Son"
About this Quote
“Approbation” is a bureaucratic word dragged into a scene of torn flesh, and the friction matters. Ratzinger is arguing against a Christianity that floats above the body and against a culture that treats suffering as meaningless noise. The line “not in words” quietly rebukes religious talk that becomes self-protective: creeds recited at a safe distance from vulnerability. For him, the Cross is divine communication at maximum stakes: incarnation followed by “pierced…to the quick,” an image that insists God’s solidarity is not metaphorical.
The subtext is also anti-sentimental. This isn’t “you are loved” as a mood; it’s love as an event that costs something concrete, even grotesque. By saying “to God, it was worth the death,” Ratzinger risks scandal on purpose. He wants to make clear that the center of the faith is not moral uplift or spiritual technique but a claim about reality: that God’s yes to humanity runs through history’s worst instrument of public humiliation.
Contextually, this sits inside Ratzinger’s lifelong campaign against reducing Christianity to ethics or politics. The Cross, in his telling, refuses both cheap optimism and despair. It forces the question: if God’s approval comes this way, what kind of life is being approved, and what kind of comfort is being refused?
Quote Details
| Topic | God |
|---|---|
| Source | Evidence: The Cross is the approbation of our existence, not in words, but in an act so completely radical that it caused God to become flesh and pierced this flesh to the quick; that, to God, it was worth the death of his incarnate Son. (Page 280). The quote is verifiably present in Joseph Ratzinger's own work Principles of Catholic Theology: Building Stones for a Fundamental Theology (Ignatius Press, 1987), where it appears on page 280 in the English translation. The surrounding passage begins: “It is good that you exist”, no, “It is necessary that you exist.” The English book appears to be a primary-source publication by Ratzinger, but it may not be the first publication of the wording in any language. Evidence strongly suggests the underlying text was published earlier in German in the 1977 Herder volume Mit der Kirche leben, which contains Ratzinger's essay Identifikation mit der Kirche. Bibliographic records confirm that book existed in 1977 and that Ratzinger's contribution was included there, but I could not directly inspect the 1977 pages to verify the exact German wording or page number of this passage. So: the earliest verifiable source I could confirm directly for the exact English wording is the 1987 book; the likely earlier original publication is Ratzinger's essay Identifikation mit der Kirche in Mit der Kirche leben (Herder, 1977). Other candidates (1) Because He Has Spoken to Us (Brad Bursa, 2022) compilation100.0% ... The Cross is the approbation of our existence , not in words , but in an act so completely radical that it caused... |
| Cite |
Citation Formats
APA Style (7th ed.)
Ratzinger, Joseph. (2026, March 8). The Cross is the approbation of our existence, not in words, but in an act so completely radical that it caused God to become flesh and pierced this flesh to the quick; that, to God, it was worth the death of his incarnate Son. FixQuotes. https://fixquotes.com/quotes/the-cross-is-the-approbation-of-our-existence-not-114313/
Chicago Style
Ratzinger, Joseph. "The Cross is the approbation of our existence, not in words, but in an act so completely radical that it caused God to become flesh and pierced this flesh to the quick; that, to God, it was worth the death of his incarnate Son." FixQuotes. March 8, 2026. https://fixquotes.com/quotes/the-cross-is-the-approbation-of-our-existence-not-114313/.
MLA Style (9th ed.)
"The Cross is the approbation of our existence, not in words, but in an act so completely radical that it caused God to become flesh and pierced this flesh to the quick; that, to God, it was worth the death of his incarnate Son." FixQuotes, 8 Mar. 2026, https://fixquotes.com/quotes/the-cross-is-the-approbation-of-our-existence-not-114313/. Accessed 31 Mar. 2026.






