"The early Church had nothing but the Old Testament. The New Testament lies hidden in the Old; the Old Testament lies open in the New"
About this Quote
There is a neat magic trick embedded in this line: it turns a sprawling, sometimes troubling library of ancient texts into a single, pre-solved puzzle with Jesus as the answer key. “Nothing but the Old Testament” sounds like historical humility, but it’s also a power move. It implies the earliest Christians weren’t innovating so much as unveiling a secret already planted in Hebrew Scripture. That framing lets later doctrinal claims present as discoveries rather than arguments.
The chiasmus does most of the work. “Hidden” and “open” are not neutral verbs; they smuggle in a hierarchy of reading. The Old Testament becomes a coded message whose full meaning is inaccessible until the New Testament decrypts it. The New Testament, in turn, is portrayed as the inevitable fulfillment of what came before, not one theological interpretation among many. It’s persuasive because it flatters the believer with coherence: history, prophecy, and identity collapse into a single storyline.
Randall Terry isn’t a cloistered theologian; he’s a culture-war celebrity who built influence by mobilizing religious conviction in public life. In that context, the quote functions as a loyalty test as much as a hermeneutic principle. If the New “opens” the Old, then dissenting Jewish readings or secular historical readings can be dismissed as willful blindness. The subtext is clear: true understanding is not merely textual competence, but allegiance to a particular Christian narrative - one that justifies certainty, urgency, and, often, confrontation.
The chiasmus does most of the work. “Hidden” and “open” are not neutral verbs; they smuggle in a hierarchy of reading. The Old Testament becomes a coded message whose full meaning is inaccessible until the New Testament decrypts it. The New Testament, in turn, is portrayed as the inevitable fulfillment of what came before, not one theological interpretation among many. It’s persuasive because it flatters the believer with coherence: history, prophecy, and identity collapse into a single storyline.
Randall Terry isn’t a cloistered theologian; he’s a culture-war celebrity who built influence by mobilizing religious conviction in public life. In that context, the quote functions as a loyalty test as much as a hermeneutic principle. If the New “opens” the Old, then dissenting Jewish readings or secular historical readings can be dismissed as willful blindness. The subtext is clear: true understanding is not merely textual competence, but allegiance to a particular Christian narrative - one that justifies certainty, urgency, and, often, confrontation.
Quote Details
| Topic | Bible |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Randall
Add to List

