"The English countryside, its growth and its destruction, is a genuine and tragic theme"
About this Quote
Forster’s line turns what could be postcard scenery into a moral plotline: the countryside is not a backdrop, it’s a protagonist with a life cycle and a body count. “Growth” sounds pastoral and organic, but in Forster’s England it also hints at the wrong kind of growth - suburban creep, rail lines, “improvement,” the polite violence of development that arrives with paperwork and good intentions. Pairing it with “destruction” refuses the sentimental idea that progress is cleanly additive. Something is always being traded away, usually by people who won’t be around to miss it.
The phrase “genuine and tragic” is doing quiet polemical work. Forster is staking a claim against the notion that nature-writing is minor art or mere nostalgia. Tragedy, in the classical sense, is what happens when forces larger than the individual - money, industry, empire, class habits - grind forward while everyone believes they’re being reasonable. That’s Forster’s specialty: social comedy that keeps revealing a harder calculus underneath.
Context matters: Forster is writing from an early 20th-century Britain where the countryside is being reorganized by modernity and by ownership. “The English countryside” is also code for a national self-image - continuity, restraint, “heritage” before the word calcifies. Calling its alteration tragic suggests not just ecological loss but spiritual and civic diminishment: a culture severing itself from the places that made its stories plausible. The intent isn’t to freeze England in amber; it’s to make the costs of “growth” readable, before they become irreversible and therefore unremarkable.
The phrase “genuine and tragic” is doing quiet polemical work. Forster is staking a claim against the notion that nature-writing is minor art or mere nostalgia. Tragedy, in the classical sense, is what happens when forces larger than the individual - money, industry, empire, class habits - grind forward while everyone believes they’re being reasonable. That’s Forster’s specialty: social comedy that keeps revealing a harder calculus underneath.
Context matters: Forster is writing from an early 20th-century Britain where the countryside is being reorganized by modernity and by ownership. “The English countryside” is also code for a national self-image - continuity, restraint, “heritage” before the word calcifies. Calling its alteration tragic suggests not just ecological loss but spiritual and civic diminishment: a culture severing itself from the places that made its stories plausible. The intent isn’t to freeze England in amber; it’s to make the costs of “growth” readable, before they become irreversible and therefore unremarkable.
Quote Details
| Topic | Nature |
|---|
More Quotes by M. Forster
Add to List
