"The first time with artistic endeavors is, if it's working, it was your idea, and if it's not, it's somebody else's idea"
About this Quote
Creative work loves a clean origin story, and Tom T. Hall is puncturing it with a songwriter’s grin. The line plays like backstage truth dressed up as a joke: when an artistic “first time” lands, everyone wants to be the genius who birthed it; when it flops, the same people scramble to subcontract blame. Hall frames that scramble in the simple grammar of the music business - “your idea” versus “somebody else’s” - because in Nashville (and in any commercial art world) authorship isn’t just ego, it’s currency. Credit buys leverage. Failure costs future chances.
The intent is less bitterness than self-defense. Hall, a storyteller who moved between art and industry, is naming the quiet negotiation that happens the moment art becomes a product: who gets to claim the spark? His phrasing hinges on “if it’s working,” as though success is the only proof of authenticity anyone cares to recognize. That’s the subtext: originality is treated as a result, not a process. People don’t ask what you risked; they ask whether it hit.
The context matters: Hall came up in a system where producers, labels, publishers, and co-writers all hover around the moment of creation. “The first time” suggests an experiment, a new sound, a daring lyric, a career pivot. His punchline admits how fragile that bravery is under a spotlight that rewards winners and memory-holes losers. It’s a wry warning to artists: protect your work, but also expect the story of it to be rewritten the second the audience votes.
The intent is less bitterness than self-defense. Hall, a storyteller who moved between art and industry, is naming the quiet negotiation that happens the moment art becomes a product: who gets to claim the spark? His phrasing hinges on “if it’s working,” as though success is the only proof of authenticity anyone cares to recognize. That’s the subtext: originality is treated as a result, not a process. People don’t ask what you risked; they ask whether it hit.
The context matters: Hall came up in a system where producers, labels, publishers, and co-writers all hover around the moment of creation. “The first time” suggests an experiment, a new sound, a daring lyric, a career pivot. His punchline admits how fragile that bravery is under a spotlight that rewards winners and memory-holes losers. It’s a wry warning to artists: protect your work, but also expect the story of it to be rewritten the second the audience votes.
Quote Details
| Topic | Witty One-Liners |
|---|
More Quotes by Tom
Add to List
