Famous quote by Nancy Cartwright

"The fundamental laws of physics do not describe true facts about reality. Rendered as descriptions of facts, they are false; amended to be true, they lose their explanatory force"

About this Quote

Nancy Cartwright's quote provides a thought-provoking critique of how the basic laws of physics are often comprehended in relation to reality. According to Cartwright, the laws of physics do not straight explain real truths about the world. Instead, when these laws are rendered as strict accurate descriptions, they become incorrect or even incorrect. This stems from the idea that the laws of physics are typically idealized models or abstractions, which streamline the complexities of the real world to make it more understandable and predictable.

By specifying that the laws are "false" when taken as actual descriptions, Cartwright highlights their limitations-- they frequently presume conditions (like smooth surface areas or perfect vacuums) that do not exist in the real world. For that reason, when physicists utilize these laws as tools for particular conditions, they must acknowledge the restrictions and idealizations involved. The "perfect gas law" in thermodynamics, for instance, works well under particular conditions but fails when applied to real gases under differing temperatures and pressures.

Cartwright also argues that if these laws were to be changed to show real-world conditions more properly, they might lose their explanatory power. Their beauty and utility frequently lie in their abstraction, which assists in the derivation of new laws and forecasts. If the laws were gotten used to represent each exception and nuance in truth, their simplicity and universal applicability might be jeopardized.

Therefore, Cartwright's quote welcomes us to reevaluate what it means for a scientific theory to be "real". It suggests that the function of clinical laws is less about offering a perfect mirror of reality and more about offering structures that help us anticipate and comprehend phenomena. This perspective lines up with a more comprehensive philosophical view that sees scientific models as instruments or tools rather than mere reflections of the world, highlighting their role in analytical and technology advancement over esoteric precision.

About the Author

USA Flag This quote is written / told by Nancy Cartwright somewhere between October 25, 1957 and today. She was a famous Actress from USA. The author also have 11 other quotes.
Go to author profile

Similar Quotes