"The fundamental problem with vi is that it doesn't have a mouse and therefore you've got all these commands"
About this Quote
Bill Joy’s jab at vi is less a gripe about ergonomics than a snapshot of a transitional moment in computing: the awkward adolescence between command-line priesthood and the coming promise of “natural” interfaces. The line lands because it’s framed as a “fundamental problem” yet points to something almost comically contingent: the absence of a mouse. That mismatch of gravitas and mundanity is the joke, and it’s also the critique.
Subtext: complexity is often a tax paid for missing affordances. Without a pointing device, vi has to turn editing into a language. You don’t just select, you “yank.” You don’t just delete, you “d.” The commands aren’t ornamentation; they’re a workaround that becomes a culture. Joy is poking at how quickly workarounds calcify into identity: the pride of mastery, the insider vocabulary, the sense that struggle equals seriousness.
Context matters. Joy helped shape Unix, a world built for speed, remote terminals, and hands on the keyboard. In that environment, vi’s terseness is a feature, not a bug: once internalized, it’s brutally efficient. His remark reads like an early warning about product design dogma: if your interface requires a catechism, you’re relying on commitment, not clarity. It’s also business logic in disguise. The mouse wasn’t just hardware; it was a mass-market on-ramp. Joy is pointing at the real competitive threat: not another editor, but an interface shift that makes the old virtuosity less valuable overnight.
Subtext: complexity is often a tax paid for missing affordances. Without a pointing device, vi has to turn editing into a language. You don’t just select, you “yank.” You don’t just delete, you “d.” The commands aren’t ornamentation; they’re a workaround that becomes a culture. Joy is poking at how quickly workarounds calcify into identity: the pride of mastery, the insider vocabulary, the sense that struggle equals seriousness.
Context matters. Joy helped shape Unix, a world built for speed, remote terminals, and hands on the keyboard. In that environment, vi’s terseness is a feature, not a bug: once internalized, it’s brutally efficient. His remark reads like an early warning about product design dogma: if your interface requires a catechism, you’re relying on commitment, not clarity. It’s also business logic in disguise. The mouse wasn’t just hardware; it was a mass-market on-ramp. Joy is pointing at the real competitive threat: not another editor, but an interface shift that makes the old virtuosity less valuable overnight.
Quote Details
| Topic | Coding & Programming |
|---|
More Quotes by Bill
Add to List
