"The great mass of humanity should never learn to read or write"
About this Quote
Lawrence drops this line like a match into a library: not as policy, but as provocation. Coming from a novelist who lived by the written word, the sentence reads less like a practical program than an anti-modern sneer at the era’s rising faith in mass literacy as automatic moral progress. The shock is the point. Lawrence is needling a culture that equated education with enlightenment, and he does it by committing the unforgivable sin for an artist: sounding contemptuous of the audience.
The intent sits in Lawrence’s broader suspicion of industrial modernity and “mental” life divorced from instinct, body, and feeling. Mass reading, in this worldview, risks producing a population fluent in slogans and abstractions, primed for bureaucracy, propaganda, and secondhand experience. The subtext isn’t “keep people stupid”; it’s “stop mistaking the ability to decode text for wisdom.” He aims at the thin, managerial rationalism of the early 20th century - the idea that more schooling would cure alienation, class conflict, spiritual exhaustion. Lawrence doubts it. He’s also poking at the democratization of culture: the fear that when everyone reads, reading itself becomes commodified, standardized, and used to manufacture consent.
Context matters: Lawrence wrote amid expanding compulsory education, mass newspapers, and the machine politics of World War I’s aftermath. The line channels a cranky, quasi-elitist modernist impulse: distrust of the crowd, disgust with “public opinion,” and anxiety that print culture can flatten the human sensorium. It works because it’s indefensible on its face, forcing the reader into the uncomfortable question Lawrence wants to smuggle in: what, exactly, did literacy buy us, and what did it train us to ignore?
The intent sits in Lawrence’s broader suspicion of industrial modernity and “mental” life divorced from instinct, body, and feeling. Mass reading, in this worldview, risks producing a population fluent in slogans and abstractions, primed for bureaucracy, propaganda, and secondhand experience. The subtext isn’t “keep people stupid”; it’s “stop mistaking the ability to decode text for wisdom.” He aims at the thin, managerial rationalism of the early 20th century - the idea that more schooling would cure alienation, class conflict, spiritual exhaustion. Lawrence doubts it. He’s also poking at the democratization of culture: the fear that when everyone reads, reading itself becomes commodified, standardized, and used to manufacture consent.
Context matters: Lawrence wrote amid expanding compulsory education, mass newspapers, and the machine politics of World War I’s aftermath. The line channels a cranky, quasi-elitist modernist impulse: distrust of the crowd, disgust with “public opinion,” and anxiety that print culture can flatten the human sensorium. It works because it’s indefensible on its face, forcing the reader into the uncomfortable question Lawrence wants to smuggle in: what, exactly, did literacy buy us, and what did it train us to ignore?
Quote Details
| Topic | Knowledge |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by David
Add to List








