"The great problem there is we have to have the cooperation of those other Asian countries"
About this Quote
Cooperation is the polite word that smuggles in hierarchy. Huntington frames “those other Asian countries” less as equal partners than as a necessary variable in an American (or Western) strategy, implying a control problem: stability can’t be engineered unilaterally, yet it still ought to be engineered. The phrase “great problem” isn’t about Asia’s complexity so much as the frustration of an outside power confronting limits. It’s bureaucratic diction with an edge: the real anxiety is that agency lies elsewhere.
The distancing language matters. “Those other” marks Asia as a bloc to be managed, not a set of distinct states with competing interests and memories of colonialism, war, and superpower meddling. It’s a small rhetorical move that does big ideological work, flattening differences in order to make the policy ask sound simpler than it is. Cooperation becomes both prerequisite and alibi: if outcomes disappoint, the failure can be blamed on insufficient buy-in from “others,” not on the premises of the plan.
Contextually, Huntington’s career-long preoccupation was power under conditions of cultural and geopolitical friction. Read alongside the worldview that later crystallized in Clash of Civilizations, the line hints at a strategic realism shaded by cultural essentialism: Asia is not just a region, but a stubborn counterpart with its own gravitational pull. The intent is pragmatic; the subtext is uneasy acknowledgment that the West can’t write the script alone, even when it still wants to cast itself as director.
The distancing language matters. “Those other” marks Asia as a bloc to be managed, not a set of distinct states with competing interests and memories of colonialism, war, and superpower meddling. It’s a small rhetorical move that does big ideological work, flattening differences in order to make the policy ask sound simpler than it is. Cooperation becomes both prerequisite and alibi: if outcomes disappoint, the failure can be blamed on insufficient buy-in from “others,” not on the premises of the plan.
Contextually, Huntington’s career-long preoccupation was power under conditions of cultural and geopolitical friction. Read alongside the worldview that later crystallized in Clash of Civilizations, the line hints at a strategic realism shaded by cultural essentialism: Asia is not just a region, but a stubborn counterpart with its own gravitational pull. The intent is pragmatic; the subtext is uneasy acknowledgment that the West can’t write the script alone, even when it still wants to cast itself as director.
Quote Details
| Topic | Peace |
|---|
More Quotes by Samuel
Add to List
