"The great thing in the world is not so much where we stand, as in what direction we are moving"
About this Quote
Progress, not posture, is the real status symbol here. Holmes is quietly demoting the idea of “standing” as a moral achievement: position, rank, even righteousness can harden into a kind of civic vanity. The line works because it swaps a static metaphor for a kinetic one. “Where we stand” conjures a snapshot people can pose for, defend, or weaponize. “What direction we are moving” forces a time axis into the argument. It’s harder to brag about motion because motion implies unfinished work and the possibility of being wrong yesterday.
Holmes Sr. wasn’t a politician issuing marching orders; he was a poet-physician steeped in a 19th-century America obsessed with improvement, reform, and self-making, yet also terrified of upheaval. That tension lives in the sentence. He grants that any given starting point might be compromised, accidental, even unjust-but he insists it’s not destiny. The subtext is corrective to moral absolutism: don’t confuse your current coordinates (class, party, creed, even personal circumstance) with your character. Character is trajectory.
There’s also a gentle rebuke to complacent privilege. If “standing” is comfort, then “direction” is responsibility: are you moving toward wider sympathy, clearer thinking, fairer arrangements? Holmes makes a reformer’s argument without sounding like a scold. It flatters the reader’s agency while denying them the easy applause of being “already there.” In a culture addicted to declaring positions, he asks the more revealing question: what are you becoming?
Holmes Sr. wasn’t a politician issuing marching orders; he was a poet-physician steeped in a 19th-century America obsessed with improvement, reform, and self-making, yet also terrified of upheaval. That tension lives in the sentence. He grants that any given starting point might be compromised, accidental, even unjust-but he insists it’s not destiny. The subtext is corrective to moral absolutism: don’t confuse your current coordinates (class, party, creed, even personal circumstance) with your character. Character is trajectory.
There’s also a gentle rebuke to complacent privilege. If “standing” is comfort, then “direction” is responsibility: are you moving toward wider sympathy, clearer thinking, fairer arrangements? Holmes makes a reformer’s argument without sounding like a scold. It flatters the reader’s agency while denying them the easy applause of being “already there.” In a culture addicted to declaring positions, he asks the more revealing question: what are you becoming?
Quote Details
| Topic | Motivational |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Oliver
Add to List
