"The higher the general average of intelligence, all things else being equal, the less the disposition to be meddlesome, critical, and overbearing"
About this Quote
It is a lawyerly flex dressed up as social advice: intelligence, Harris suggests, should make you quieter, not louder. The line flatters the listener and scolds them in the same breath. If you feel tempted to correct people, insert yourself, run the room, the quote implies you might not be as smart as you think. The elegance is in the conditional clause, "all things else being equal", a courtroom hedge that pretends to be objective while smuggling in a moral ranking: the truly intelligent are the least irritating.
The subtext is about civic temperament. Harris lived in an era when professional men were building modern institutions and clubs, selling "service" as a stabilizing virtue against both elite arrogance and mass agitation. Read through that lens, the target isn’t just the loudmouth; it’s the petty authority figure, the moral busybody, the person who turns community into surveillance. Intelligence becomes a proxy for self-control and humility, a claim that justifies leadership by promising restraint.
It also contains a subtle piece of class-coded persuasion. "Meddlesome" and "overbearing" are accusations often aimed at people climbing social ladders, those who overcompensate by policing manners and status. Harris reframes good citizenship as non-domination: the smartest person in the room doesn’t need to win every room.
Of course, the premise is debatable. Intelligence can sharpen critique and amplify ego. But that’s why the sentence works: it offers a social ideal - competence without contempt - and uses the listener’s self-image as leverage to get them there.
The subtext is about civic temperament. Harris lived in an era when professional men were building modern institutions and clubs, selling "service" as a stabilizing virtue against both elite arrogance and mass agitation. Read through that lens, the target isn’t just the loudmouth; it’s the petty authority figure, the moral busybody, the person who turns community into surveillance. Intelligence becomes a proxy for self-control and humility, a claim that justifies leadership by promising restraint.
It also contains a subtle piece of class-coded persuasion. "Meddlesome" and "overbearing" are accusations often aimed at people climbing social ladders, those who overcompensate by policing manners and status. Harris reframes good citizenship as non-domination: the smartest person in the room doesn’t need to win every room.
Of course, the premise is debatable. Intelligence can sharpen critique and amplify ego. But that’s why the sentence works: it offers a social ideal - competence without contempt - and uses the listener’s self-image as leverage to get them there.
Quote Details
| Topic | Humility |
|---|
More Quotes by Paul
Add to List
