"The idea is that if we can put our own people through something almost as bad as what they might have to go through if they were taken captive, they will inoculate themselves"
About this Quote
A cold-blooded logic hides inside that soothing verb: "inoculate". Mayer is quoting a worldview that tries to launder brutality through the language of public health, as if suffering can be dosed, managed, and ultimately made patriotic. The sentence builds a moral alibi in real time: "our own people" activates tribal care, "almost as bad" pretends to draw a humane line, and "they might have to" smuggles speculation into the role of inevitability. By the time we reach "taken captive", the horror is outsourced to a hypothetical enemy, and what follows is sold as mere preparation rather than deliberate harm.
The intent is not simply to describe harsh training; it's to make pre-emptive cruelty sound like prudence. The subtext is bureaucratic: pain becomes a tool, trauma becomes a curriculum, and responsibility gets blurred by conditional verbs. "The idea is that" also matters. It's Mayer signaling distance, framing the rationale as an artifact to be examined, not a belief to be shared. That slight rhetorical remove is what journalists use when the facts are damning but the speaker wants the reader to hear the system's own justifications in its own voice.
Contextually, Mayer's reporting often excavates how national-security institutions normalize ethically radioactive practices (think SERE-derived techniques and post-9/11 interrogation policy). The quote captures the pivot from defense to self-inflicted damage: a nation so anxious about what might be done to its agents that it permits itself to do nearly the same thing first, then calls it resilience.
The intent is not simply to describe harsh training; it's to make pre-emptive cruelty sound like prudence. The subtext is bureaucratic: pain becomes a tool, trauma becomes a curriculum, and responsibility gets blurred by conditional verbs. "The idea is that" also matters. It's Mayer signaling distance, framing the rationale as an artifact to be examined, not a belief to be shared. That slight rhetorical remove is what journalists use when the facts are damning but the speaker wants the reader to hear the system's own justifications in its own voice.
Contextually, Mayer's reporting often excavates how national-security institutions normalize ethically radioactive practices (think SERE-derived techniques and post-9/11 interrogation policy). The quote captures the pivot from defense to self-inflicted damage: a nation so anxious about what might be done to its agents that it permits itself to do nearly the same thing first, then calls it resilience.
Quote Details
| Topic | Military & Soldier |
|---|
More Quotes by Jane
Add to List
