"The Indians kept increasing in numbers until it was estimated that we were fighting from 800 to 1,000 of them"
About this Quote
The line reads like a field report, but it’s really stagecraft: a casual inflation of danger that turns a messy frontier skirmish into a clean, saleable epic. “Kept increasing in numbers” has the logic of a campfire tale, the enemy multiplying as the storyteller warms to his own suspense. The estimate “800 to 1,000” isn’t precision; it’s plausible math for audiences who want realism without verification. Numbers, in this context, don’t measure people so much as they measure heroism: the larger the opposing force, the more inevitable Buffalo Bill’s bravery becomes.
The subtext is the most American kind of self-mythology: risk management for the conscience. By casting Indigenous fighters as a swelling mass, the quote strips them of individuality and motive, turning them into weather - a force of nature rolling in on the brave “we.” That “we” matters. It recruits the listener into the settler perspective, making the conflict feel communal and defensive, not expansionist. If you’re “fighting” a near-thousand, then fear is justified, violence is preemptive, and victory is destiny.
Context does the rest. Cody wasn’t just a participant in the Indian Wars; he was their publicist-in-chief, packaging the West for Eastern crowds and European royalty through Wild West shows, dime-novel beats, and a brand built on frontier authenticity. The intent here is less to remember accurately than to persuade efficiently: enlarge the threat, sanctify the response, and keep the legend rentable.
The subtext is the most American kind of self-mythology: risk management for the conscience. By casting Indigenous fighters as a swelling mass, the quote strips them of individuality and motive, turning them into weather - a force of nature rolling in on the brave “we.” That “we” matters. It recruits the listener into the settler perspective, making the conflict feel communal and defensive, not expansionist. If you’re “fighting” a near-thousand, then fear is justified, violence is preemptive, and victory is destiny.
Context does the rest. Cody wasn’t just a participant in the Indian Wars; he was their publicist-in-chief, packaging the West for Eastern crowds and European royalty through Wild West shows, dime-novel beats, and a brand built on frontier authenticity. The intent here is less to remember accurately than to persuade efficiently: enlarge the threat, sanctify the response, and keep the legend rentable.
Quote Details
| Topic | War |
|---|
More Quotes by Buffalo
Add to List

