"The information I requested under the Freedom of Information Act has been blocked for two years"
About this Quote
Two years is the tell. Edmonds isn’t just complaining about paperwork; she’s showing how a democracy can quietly reclassify accountability as an administrative inconvenience. The sentence is plain, almost sterile, and that’s the point: it mimics the bureaucratic tone that so often smothers public scrutiny. There’s no flourish, no outrage-word. Just a clock, a law, and a blockage. The emotional charge comes from the mismatch between what FOIA promises in civic mythology (sunlight on demand) and what it delivers in practice (sunlight, pending review).
The specific intent reads like a pressure point: to document a procedural failure in a way that can’t be dismissed as personal grievance. “The information I requested” centers a legitimate, rule-following citizen-actor; “under the Freedom of Information Act” invokes a statutory right, not a favor; “has been blocked” shifts agency back onto the state. Passive voice here isn’t evasive, it’s accusatory: the system is designed so responsibility dissolves into process.
Edmonds’ context matters because she’s a public servant and whistleblower-adjacent figure, speaking from inside the civic machinery rather than from the commentariat. That position sharpens the subtext: if even an insider, armed with the proper legal tool, can be stalled for years, then FOIA becomes less a transparency guarantee than a reputational shield. Delay functions as soft censorship: information withheld long enough becomes information denied, without anyone ever having to say “no.”
The specific intent reads like a pressure point: to document a procedural failure in a way that can’t be dismissed as personal grievance. “The information I requested” centers a legitimate, rule-following citizen-actor; “under the Freedom of Information Act” invokes a statutory right, not a favor; “has been blocked” shifts agency back onto the state. Passive voice here isn’t evasive, it’s accusatory: the system is designed so responsibility dissolves into process.
Edmonds’ context matters because she’s a public servant and whistleblower-adjacent figure, speaking from inside the civic machinery rather than from the commentariat. That position sharpens the subtext: if even an insider, armed with the proper legal tool, can be stalled for years, then FOIA becomes less a transparency guarantee than a reputational shield. Delay functions as soft censorship: information withheld long enough becomes information denied, without anyone ever having to say “no.”
Quote Details
| Topic | Freedom |
|---|
More Quotes by Sibel
Add to List


