"The intellectual is a middle-class product; if he is not born into the class he must soon insert himself into it, in order to exist. He is the fine nervous flower of the bourgeoisie"
About this Quote
Bogan’s line lands like a slap at the genteel myth of the free-floating mind. The “intellectual” here isn’t a heroic outsider but a creature with a habitat: the middle class, with its leisure, credentials, and soft infrastructure of salons, magazines, universities, and paying readers. Calling the intellectual a “product” drains the romance from the role. Ideas, in this view, aren’t born in pure abstraction; they’re manufactured in a social economy that supplies time, status, and the expectation of being heard.
The subtext is less anti-intellectual than anti-innocence. Bogan isn’t arguing that thought is worthless; she’s arguing that thought has a class address. If you’re not “born into the class,” you must “insert” yourself into it “in order to exist” - a blunt acknowledgment of assimilation as survival. The verb choice matters: insert suggests an awkward, deliberate fit, not a natural belonging. Intellectual life becomes not just vocation but a form of social passing.
Then she sharpens the knife with “fine nervous flower.” It’s an image of refinement and fragility, something cultivated in controlled conditions, easily bruised. “Nervous” hints at sensitivity that can read as insight or as bourgeois overstimulation: a temperament shaped by comfort and anxiety in equal measure.
Contextually, coming from a poet who worked in a literary culture increasingly professionalized in the 20th century, it reads as self-aware critique. Bogan is watching the intellectual class solidify into a recognizable type - and refusing to pretend it’s above the very bourgeois world that keeps it alive.
The subtext is less anti-intellectual than anti-innocence. Bogan isn’t arguing that thought is worthless; she’s arguing that thought has a class address. If you’re not “born into the class,” you must “insert” yourself into it “in order to exist” - a blunt acknowledgment of assimilation as survival. The verb choice matters: insert suggests an awkward, deliberate fit, not a natural belonging. Intellectual life becomes not just vocation but a form of social passing.
Then she sharpens the knife with “fine nervous flower.” It’s an image of refinement and fragility, something cultivated in controlled conditions, easily bruised. “Nervous” hints at sensitivity that can read as insight or as bourgeois overstimulation: a temperament shaped by comfort and anxiety in equal measure.
Contextually, coming from a poet who worked in a literary culture increasingly professionalized in the 20th century, it reads as self-aware critique. Bogan is watching the intellectual class solidify into a recognizable type - and refusing to pretend it’s above the very bourgeois world that keeps it alive.
Quote Details
| Topic | Equality |
|---|
More Quotes by Louise
Add to List
