"The intellectual tradition is one of servility to power, and if I didn't betray it I'd be ashamed of myself"
About this Quote
Servility is a knife twist here, because it’s aimed at the very class that likes to imagine itself as society’s immune system. Chomsky’s line doesn’t flatter “the intellectual tradition” as a noble inheritance; it indicts it as a court culture: credentialed people laundering elite interests into respectable ideas. The provocation sits in the word betray. Betrayal is usually moral failure, but Chomsky flips it into moral hygiene. If the tradition is structured to rationalize power, then loyalty becomes complicity, and shame attaches to obedience, not dissent.
The subtext is a critique of how knowledge gets socially rewarded. Intellectuals aren’t coerced into conformity; they’re compensated for it, with status, access, and the soothing story that they’re being “responsible” or “pragmatic.” That’s why the sentence lands: it frames the problem as institutional, not psychological. It’s not that smart people are uniquely cowardly; it’s that the ecosystem of grants, media platforms, think tanks, and proximity to decision-makers selects for those who translate power’s needs into policy language and moral alibis.
Context matters: Chomsky has spent decades targeting liberal technocracy as much as overt authoritarianism, arguing that in democracies propaganda works best when it’s administered by professionals who believe they’re above propaganda. The line is also self-positioning. He’s telling you his posture is not contrarian theater; it’s a refusal of an inherited job description. If the default role is to serve, “betrayal” becomes the baseline requirement for intellectual honesty.
The subtext is a critique of how knowledge gets socially rewarded. Intellectuals aren’t coerced into conformity; they’re compensated for it, with status, access, and the soothing story that they’re being “responsible” or “pragmatic.” That’s why the sentence lands: it frames the problem as institutional, not psychological. It’s not that smart people are uniquely cowardly; it’s that the ecosystem of grants, media platforms, think tanks, and proximity to decision-makers selects for those who translate power’s needs into policy language and moral alibis.
Context matters: Chomsky has spent decades targeting liberal technocracy as much as overt authoritarianism, arguing that in democracies propaganda works best when it’s administered by professionals who believe they’re above propaganda. The line is also self-positioning. He’s telling you his posture is not contrarian theater; it’s a refusal of an inherited job description. If the default role is to serve, “betrayal” becomes the baseline requirement for intellectual honesty.
Quote Details
| Topic | Ethics & Morality |
|---|
More Quotes by Noam
Add to List









