"The irrationality of a thing is no argument against its existence, rather a condition of it"
About this Quote
Nietzsche pulls a rug out from under the Enlightenment habit of treating reason as a border patrol: if you can’t justify it, it shouldn’t be allowed to count as real. His line is a provocation dressed as a principle. “Irrationality” isn’t a defect to be corrected; it’s often the very signature of life as it is actually lived. Belief, desire, cruelty, loyalty, art, faith, ressentiment, even the itch for “truth” itself - these aren’t clean syllogisms. They persist precisely because they answer needs deeper than logic: the need to endure, to dominate, to belong, to give suffering a shape.
The intent is tactical. Nietzsche is attacking the moral-philosophical move that smuggles values in under the banner of rational necessity. When people dismiss religion, myth, or instinct as “irrational,” they usually mean “illegitimate.” Nietzsche replies: nice try. The world did not ask for your permission to be messy. If anything, the demand that reality conform to rational standards is the oddity - a psychological craving for control, predictability, and innocence.
Context matters: late 19th-century Europe is drunk on science, progress, and system-building philosophy, while Nietzsche is diagnosing a culture sliding into nihilism after the “death of God.” He’s warning that debunking irrational structures doesn’t delete them; it just drives them underground, where they return as politics, mass movements, moral panics. The sting is that rationalism, too, has its irrational core: a faith in reason as salvation. Nietzsche’s wager is that honesty begins where our justifications fail.
The intent is tactical. Nietzsche is attacking the moral-philosophical move that smuggles values in under the banner of rational necessity. When people dismiss religion, myth, or instinct as “irrational,” they usually mean “illegitimate.” Nietzsche replies: nice try. The world did not ask for your permission to be messy. If anything, the demand that reality conform to rational standards is the oddity - a psychological craving for control, predictability, and innocence.
Context matters: late 19th-century Europe is drunk on science, progress, and system-building philosophy, while Nietzsche is diagnosing a culture sliding into nihilism after the “death of God.” He’s warning that debunking irrational structures doesn’t delete them; it just drives them underground, where they return as politics, mass movements, moral panics. The sting is that rationalism, too, has its irrational core: a faith in reason as salvation. Nietzsche’s wager is that honesty begins where our justifications fail.
Quote Details
| Topic | Reason & Logic |
|---|
More Quotes by Friedrich
Add to List





