"The issue is not abortion. The issue is whether women can make up their own mind instead of some right-wing pastor, some right-wing politician telling them what to do"
About this Quote
Dean’s line is a deliberate reframing, less a meditation on abortion than a political judo move: stop arguing about the procedure and force the debate onto power. By declaring “the issue is not abortion,” he sidesteps the moral labyrinth opponents want to litigate endlessly and relocates the fight to a simpler, harder-to-defend question: who gets to decide. It’s a choice of terrain, and it’s aimed at winning.
The repeated “right-wing” isn’t just emphasis; it’s an attempt to fuse two authorities that can make swing voters uneasy in different ways: clerical power and partisan power. The “pastor” invokes religious coercion; the “politician” invokes state coercion. Put together, they sketch an alliance that threatens personal freedom, especially for people who might not identify as pro-choice ideologues but bristle at being managed. Dean’s cadence also matters: “some right-wing pastor, some right-wing politician” makes them feel interchangeable, interchangeable enough to be dismissed as busybodies rather than moral leaders.
Subtextually, it’s a defensive move from a Democrat in the culture-war crosshairs of the early 2000s: abortion is a losing word in many districts, autonomy is not. By centering “women can make up their own mind,” Dean appeals to dignity and competence, casting women not as patients or symbols but as agents. The real target isn’t fetal personhood; it’s the legitimacy of gatekeepers who claim to speak for women while demanding obedience.
The repeated “right-wing” isn’t just emphasis; it’s an attempt to fuse two authorities that can make swing voters uneasy in different ways: clerical power and partisan power. The “pastor” invokes religious coercion; the “politician” invokes state coercion. Put together, they sketch an alliance that threatens personal freedom, especially for people who might not identify as pro-choice ideologues but bristle at being managed. Dean’s cadence also matters: “some right-wing pastor, some right-wing politician” makes them feel interchangeable, interchangeable enough to be dismissed as busybodies rather than moral leaders.
Subtextually, it’s a defensive move from a Democrat in the culture-war crosshairs of the early 2000s: abortion is a losing word in many districts, autonomy is not. By centering “women can make up their own mind,” Dean appeals to dignity and competence, casting women not as patients or symbols but as agents. The real target isn’t fetal personhood; it’s the legitimacy of gatekeepers who claim to speak for women while demanding obedience.
Quote Details
| Topic | Freedom |
|---|
More Quotes by Howard
Add to List
