"The judge decided in this case that both the state and the defense would have the opportunity to respond to certain kinds of press. This is one such instance"
About this Quote
Power hides in the blandness of legal procedure, and Catherine Crier knows it. Her line reads like a neutral stage direction, but it’s really a compact warning about who gets to narrate justice in real time. By invoking “the judge decided,” she shifts agency upward to the court, framing the moment as sanctioned, orderly, and therefore legitimate. That’s not just attribution; it’s insulation. If what follows is contentious, the authority has already been preloaded.
The key phrase is “certain kinds of press,” a deliberately foggy category that hints at a hierarchy inside “the media” itself: some coverage is treated as background noise, other coverage as influential enough to require formal rebuttal. Crier’s subtext: in high-profile cases, headlines and camera angles can function like unofficial evidence, shaping jurors, voters, and the reputations of institutions long before a verdict. The court, acknowledging that reality, effectively creates a procedural valve for managing narrative pressure.
“This is one such instance” is the quiet pivot from abstract policy to immediate action. It tells the audience: what you’re about to hear isn’t mere commentary; it’s an authorized countermove in a media chess match. Coming from a journalist, the sentence also carries a meta-journalistic edge: she’s documenting the court’s attempt to domesticate publicity while participating in the very ecosystem being managed. The result is a line that sounds impartial yet exposes a modern truth: trials don’t just happen in courtrooms anymore; they happen in the press, and the bench knows it.
The key phrase is “certain kinds of press,” a deliberately foggy category that hints at a hierarchy inside “the media” itself: some coverage is treated as background noise, other coverage as influential enough to require formal rebuttal. Crier’s subtext: in high-profile cases, headlines and camera angles can function like unofficial evidence, shaping jurors, voters, and the reputations of institutions long before a verdict. The court, acknowledging that reality, effectively creates a procedural valve for managing narrative pressure.
“This is one such instance” is the quiet pivot from abstract policy to immediate action. It tells the audience: what you’re about to hear isn’t mere commentary; it’s an authorized countermove in a media chess match. Coming from a journalist, the sentence also carries a meta-journalistic edge: she’s documenting the court’s attempt to domesticate publicity while participating in the very ecosystem being managed. The result is a line that sounds impartial yet exposes a modern truth: trials don’t just happen in courtrooms anymore; they happen in the press, and the bench knows it.
Quote Details
| Topic | Justice |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Catherine
Add to List

