"The knowledge that makes us cherish innocence makes innocence unattainable"
About this Quote
Innocence doesn’t die from experience alone; it dies from the awareness of what innocence costs. Howe’s line turns a familiar nostalgia story into a trap: the very knowledge that teaches you to prize purity also installs the suspicion that purity is a pose, a privilege, or a lie you can’t honestly inhabit anymore. The sentence is built like a paradox because the feeling it names is paradoxical: to “cherish” innocence is already to stand outside it, looking back with a connoisseur’s eye.
Howe, a historian and critic shaped by the moral wreckage of the 20th century, is writing against sentimental longings for a cleaner past. After genocide, ideological terror, and the mass politics that made cruelty bureaucratic, innocence becomes less a personal quality than a cultural fantasy. Knowledge here isn’t just information; it’s historical consciousness, the burden of patterns. Once you recognize how easily innocence can be weaponized (by states, by movements, by ourselves), you can’t return to it without bad faith.
The subtext is also about adulthood in intellectual life: learning to see complicity. The more you understand systems, the harder it is to claim you “didn’t know,” the hardest-working excuse innocence has. Howe suggests that moral growth contains its own grief. We mourn innocence precisely when we’re no longer entitled to it, which is why the longing feels both tender and accusatory. The line lands because it refuses comfort: it grants the desire, then denies the alibi.
Howe, a historian and critic shaped by the moral wreckage of the 20th century, is writing against sentimental longings for a cleaner past. After genocide, ideological terror, and the mass politics that made cruelty bureaucratic, innocence becomes less a personal quality than a cultural fantasy. Knowledge here isn’t just information; it’s historical consciousness, the burden of patterns. Once you recognize how easily innocence can be weaponized (by states, by movements, by ourselves), you can’t return to it without bad faith.
The subtext is also about adulthood in intellectual life: learning to see complicity. The more you understand systems, the harder it is to claim you “didn’t know,” the hardest-working excuse innocence has. Howe suggests that moral growth contains its own grief. We mourn innocence precisely when we’re no longer entitled to it, which is why the longing feels both tender and accusatory. The line lands because it refuses comfort: it grants the desire, then denies the alibi.
Quote Details
| Topic | Wisdom |
|---|
More Quotes by Irving
Add to List







