"The legal system is often a mystery, and we, its priests, preside over rituals baffling to everyday citizens"
About this Quote
Miller’s jab lands because it frames the courthouse not as a temple of reason but as a temple, full stop: guarded knowledge, rehearsed gestures, and a faithful public expected to submit. Calling lawyers “priests” is less metaphor than indictment. Priests don’t just interpret doctrine; they monopolize it. The line suggests the legal system’s authority is sustained by mystification as much as by justice, with procedure functioning like liturgy: impressive, opaque, and ultimately self-justifying.
The real sting is in “we.” Miller doesn’t merely sneer from the outside; he implicates the educated class that profits from complexity. That first-person plural turns critique into confession. It also sidesteps the easy populist caricature of dumb citizens versus smart professionals. Instead, he sketches a closed ecosystem where insiders translate the world into a specialized language, then treat that language as proof of legitimacy.
Contextually, Miller is writing out of a 20th-century modernist suspicion of institutions that claim moral authority while operating like machines. In his work, bureaucracy and respectability often look like elaborate performances designed to domesticate messier human realities. Here, “rituals baffling to everyday citizens” points to a democratic failure: the law is supposed to be public, yet it is experienced as esoteric. The subtext isn’t that law should be simple-minded; it’s that when complexity becomes a moat, the system stops serving the public and starts staging its own power.
The real sting is in “we.” Miller doesn’t merely sneer from the outside; he implicates the educated class that profits from complexity. That first-person plural turns critique into confession. It also sidesteps the easy populist caricature of dumb citizens versus smart professionals. Instead, he sketches a closed ecosystem where insiders translate the world into a specialized language, then treat that language as proof of legitimacy.
Contextually, Miller is writing out of a 20th-century modernist suspicion of institutions that claim moral authority while operating like machines. In his work, bureaucracy and respectability often look like elaborate performances designed to domesticate messier human realities. Here, “rituals baffling to everyday citizens” points to a democratic failure: the law is supposed to be public, yet it is experienced as esoteric. The subtext isn’t that law should be simple-minded; it’s that when complexity becomes a moat, the system stops serving the public and starts staging its own power.
Quote Details
| Topic | Justice |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Henry
Add to List





