"The lyrics are different from Nick Cave songs and lyrics. His songs are very narrative"
About this Quote
Malkmus is doing that classic musician move: drawing a boundary without picking a fight. By saying “different from Nick Cave songs and lyrics,” he’s not just comparing styles; he’s quietly defending another mode of songwriting against Cave’s towering reputation for gothic storytelling. Cave, in the rock canon, is the high priest of the plot-heavy song: murder ballads, biblical dread, characters with names and sins. “Very narrative” reads like both praise and a gentle box to put him in.
The subtext is about what gets treated as “serious” in lyric-writing. Narrative songs are easy to crown because they resemble literature: scene, arc, memorable protagonists. Malkmus, coming out of indie rock’s slacker-intellectual wing, has often worked in a different prestige economy: collage, misdirection, tone, the sentence that feels like it means three things at once. So the line implies an alternative standard: lyrics can be compelling without delivering a neatly reportable story.
Context matters because Malkmus is a songwriter constantly measured against other “lyric guys,” and Cave is a shorthand for a certain kind of gravitas. Calling Cave narrative is accurate, but it also sidesteps the more nebulous qualities - voice, menace, comedy, spiritual hunger - that make Cave more than a novelist with a guitar. That’s the point: Malkmus is narrowing the frame to make room for other approaches, insisting that difference isn’t deficiency, it’s design.
The subtext is about what gets treated as “serious” in lyric-writing. Narrative songs are easy to crown because they resemble literature: scene, arc, memorable protagonists. Malkmus, coming out of indie rock’s slacker-intellectual wing, has often worked in a different prestige economy: collage, misdirection, tone, the sentence that feels like it means three things at once. So the line implies an alternative standard: lyrics can be compelling without delivering a neatly reportable story.
Context matters because Malkmus is a songwriter constantly measured against other “lyric guys,” and Cave is a shorthand for a certain kind of gravitas. Calling Cave narrative is accurate, but it also sidesteps the more nebulous qualities - voice, menace, comedy, spiritual hunger - that make Cave more than a novelist with a guitar. That’s the point: Malkmus is narrowing the frame to make room for other approaches, insisting that difference isn’t deficiency, it’s design.
Quote Details
| Topic | Music |
|---|
More Quotes by Stephen
Add to List
